Entrepreneurship in Action, 21-24 Nov, online. Build a working product with AI

How Do Carbon Markets Put a Price on Emissions? | How It Works

12 min read

On this page

What is the short answer?

When a power station burns coal, the people harmed by a hotter climate do not send it a bill. Economists call such an unpaid cost a negative externality. A carbon market makes emitters pay it.

A government sets a cap on the greenhouse gases a group of firms may emit and issues that many allowances, one per tonne. Firms that cut cheaply sell spare allowances to firms that cannot. Trading gives each tonne a price.

Definition: Cap-and-trade, or an emissions trading system (ETS), limits total emissions from covered sources and lets firms buy and sell the allowances that make up the limit. The carbon price is the market price of one allowance.

How does a cap-and-trade system work?

The rules list the covered sources, such as power stations and steelworks. In the European Union's system, an allowance permits one tonne of carbon dioxide equivalent (CO2e): a tonne of CO2, or an amount of another greenhouse gas with the same warming effect.

Firms get allowances through auctioning, bidding for them, or free allocation, when the government hands them out. In the EU, auctioning has been the default since 2013.

Each year, a firm monitors and reports its emissions, which are then verified, and must surrender one allowance per tonne; in the EU, by 30 September of the next year. A firm that falls short pays a penalty and still owes the missing allowances.

Banking lets firms keep unused allowances; the EU has allowed it since 2008. The cap also falls. In the EU's 2021 to 2030 phase, a linear reduction factor sets the yearly cut: 4.3% for 2024 to 2027, then 4.4% from 2028.

Why do firms trade, and how does that set a price?

Firms differ in how cheaply they can cut. One may switch fuel; another may need a new furnace. The cost of cutting one more tonne is the marginal abatement cost.

Each firm compares that cost with the allowance price. If a cut is cheaper, it cuts and sells the spare allowance; if it is dearer, it buys. The cheapest cuts happen first, so the cap is met at a lower total cost.

The cap fixes the supply of allowances. Demand moves with the economy, fuel prices and technology. The price settles near the cost of the last tonne firms choose to cut, so it can swing while the cap stays put.

How is a carbon tax different?

A carbon tax fixes the price of a tonne and lets emissions vary. Cap-and-trade fixes the quantity and lets the price vary. Supporters of a tax value price certainty, which helps firms plan long-term investments. Supporters of a cap value quantity certainty: the cap limits covered emissions, whatever the economy does.

Sweden introduced a carbon tax in 1991, at SEK 250 a tonne of fossil CO2. In 2026, the rate for natural gas and coal is SEK 1,520 a tonne. Swedish industry inside the EU's trading system is exempt from the tax, so the two tools cover different emitters side by side.

What stops the carbon price swinging too far?

A pure cap lets the price go anywhere. Prices too low weaken the reason to cut; prices too high strain firms and households. Most systems add safeguards.

After the 2008 economic crisis cut emissions and international credits added supply, the EU's surplus passed 2.1 billion allowances by 2013, and prices fell. Its Market Stability Reserve (MSR), operating since 2019, now absorbs part of the surplus when more than 833 million allowances are in circulation, and releases 100 million when fewer than 400 million are.

California's price floor, its auction reserve price, is $27.94 in 2026, and its price ceiling is $102.52. Both rise each year by 5% plus inflation.

The Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI), a power-sector market run by eastern states of the United States such as New York, counts allowances in short tons of CO2. It sells extra allowances from a Cost Containment Reserve if prices pass $18.22 in 2026. Most member states withhold allowances through an Emissions Containment Reserve if prices fall below $8.41.

Where do the main carbon markets run today?

The European Union. Launched in 2005, the EU ETS was the world's first carbon market. It covers power, industry and aviation, about 40% of EU greenhouse gas emissions, plus shipping since 2024. A 2023 reform aims for a 62% cut in covered emissions by 2030, compared with 2005.

ETS2, a second system for fuel used in buildings and road transport, was due in 2027; a change to EU climate law in 2026 moved its full start to 2028.

China. China's national ETS was launched in July 2021 for power, and by early 2025 covered about 2,200 coal-fired power companies. In 2025, it began adding about 1,500 steel, cement and aluminium firms, bringing more than 60% of China's CO2 emissions under the market. Its free allowances follow output, so there is no fixed total. China plans to cover all major industrial emitters by 2027.

California and Quebec. California's program has bound emitters since 2013 and covers about 76% of the state's emissions. Since January 2014, it has been linked with Quebec, a province of Canada, and the two hold joint auctions. Laws passed in 2025 extended it to 2045 as cap-and-invest.

India. India notified its Carbon Credit Trading Scheme on 28 June 2023. It sets emission intensity targets, limits on greenhouse gas per unit of output, rather than a total cap. Entities that beat them earn certificates to sell. By January 2026, 490 obligated entities had targets.

How do offsets and credits differ from allowances?

An allowance is created by the cap. A carbon credit, or offset, comes from a project outside the cap that claims to cut or remove emissions, such as a protected forest. Its value rests on its baseline, the estimate of what would have happened anyway.

Compliance markets limit offsets. The EU ETS bars them in its current phase. California allows them for up to 6% of a firm's obligation from 2026, and China for up to 5% of verified emissions.

Article 6 of the Paris Agreement, adopted in 2015, lets countries transfer emission cuts towards their national targets without double counting, and set up a UN-supervised crediting mechanism. Countries agreed rules for this UN-backed market at COP29 in November 2024.

In the voluntary market, companies buy credits to back climate claims. A 2025 US Government Accountability Office report noted questions about whether credits produce the benefits they claim. From 27 September 2026, EU law bans claims that a product has a neutral or reduced climate impact based on offsetting.

What do supporters and critics argue?

Effectiveness. Supporters cite the European Commission: by 2023, the EU ETS had helped cut emissions from power and industry plants by about 47% compared with 2005. Critics note the cap was loose for years; the Commission says the surplus brought low prices that weakened the reason to cut.

Carbon leakage. Production may move to places with weaker climate rules. The EU responds with free allowances for industries at risk and with the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM), a charge on the carbon in imported cement, iron and steel, aluminium, fertilisers, electricity and hydrogen.

From October 2023 to the end of 2025, importers only reported emissions. Since 1 January 2026, they owe certificates, priced from EU ETS auctions and bought from February 2027.

Windfall profits. A firm given free allowances can still charge customers their market value. The Commission says auctioning eliminates such windfall profits, though free allocation continues for industries at risk of leakage.

Fairness. India's government said in 2024 that CBAM may raise the compliance burden on its steel exports, and that concerns had been raised at the WTO. The EU says CBAM makes import prices reflect embedded emissions. A Social Climate Fund is expected to mobilise at least €86.7 billion in 2026 to 2032 for vulnerable EU households and micro-enterprises facing ETS2.

How does this work with real numbers?

Both examples use illustrative numbers.

How does trading lower the cost of meeting a cap?

Two firms each emit 100,000 tonnes a year and get 80,000 allowances, so they must cut 40,000 tonnes. Firm A can cut up to 40,000 tonnes at $20 a tonne; Firm B only at $60.

Table: Illustrative cost of meeting the same cap

CaseFirm A cutsFirm B cutsTotal cost
No trading20,000 t × $20 = $400,00020,000 t × $60 = $1,200,000$1,600,000
Trading40,000 t × $20 = $800,0000 t = $0$800,000

With trading, A cuts 40,000 tonnes and sells 20,000 spare allowances to B. Emissions still equal the 160,000-tonne cap, at $800,000 less.

Any price between $20 and $60 helps both: A earns more than its $20 cut costs, and B pays less than its $60. At $40, A's sales of 20,000 × $40 = $800,000 cover its bill, and B pays $800,000, not $1,200,000. Each saves $400,000.

What happens in one firm's compliance year?

A factory emits 120,000 tonnes. It holds 70,000 free allowances, 5,000 banked, 30,000 from auction and 10,000 from other firms: 115,000 in all. It is 5,000 short.

Take a price of €70 an allowance and a penalty of €100 a tonne; EU law sets €100 and raises it with European consumer prices, so the real figure differs. Buying 5,000 more in time costs 5,000 × €70 = €350,000.

Falling short costs 5,000 × €100 = €500,000, and the factory must still surrender the 5,000 allowances the next year, another €350,000: €850,000 in all, or €500,000 more than buying in time.

Where can the student go deeper in World 101?

This page follows one mechanism: how a cap, tradable allowances and a few safeguards give pollution a price. The World 101 subject Market Failure and Externalities covers the wider idea of why markets misprice harms that fall on bystanders, such as pollution, and the range of fixes, from rules to taxes.

Three related subjects go further. Carbon Markets and Net Zero places carbon pricing inside the plan to bring net emissions to zero. Taxation explains how governments design taxes, including the carbon tax that rivals cap-and-trade. International Trade and Global Finance covers tariffs and trade disputes, where border charges such as CBAM are argued over.

Sources

  • European Commission, "About the EU ETS" (launch, 2005; 2030 goal), "Market Stability Reserve" (2008 crisis; 2013 surplus; MSR since 2019), "Auctioning of allowances" and "ETS2" (fund to 2032), read 7 November 2026.
  • European Commission, news on the 2024 EU ETS cap (4.3% to 2027; 4.4% from 2028), 28 July 2023.
  • Directive 2003/87/EC, consolidated text of 1 March 2024.
  • European Parliament, press release on the EU climate law and ETS2, 10 February 2026.
  • European Commission, CBAM pages, read 7 November 2026; news of 17 August 2023.
  • ICAP factsheets on the EU ETS (banking since 2008; 2021 to 2030 phase), China and California (from 2013; Quebec link, 2014; to 2045), read 7 November 2026.
  • RGGI, "Elements of RGGI", read 7 November 2026.
  • China Daily and Xinhua on english.www.gov.cn, 27 March 2025 (launched 2021) and 24 November 2025.
  • Press Information Bureau, India, releases of 9 December 2024, 9 August 2024 and 22 January 2026.
  • Government Offices of Sweden, "Sweden's carbon tax" (introduced 1991), read 7 November 2026.
  • Paris Agreement, Article 6, adopted 12 December 2015; UN News on COP29, 23 November 2024.
  • US Government Accountability Office, GAO-25-107128, 13 August 2025; Directive (EU) 2024/825.

Common errors and misconceptions

  • Misconception: A carbon market lets firms pollute without limit if they pay. Correct: Covered emissions cannot exceed the cap plus any reserve allowances; each tonne one firm buys is a tonne another does not emit.
  • Misconception: In cap-and-trade, the government sets the carbon price. Correct: It sets the quantity; the price comes from trading, within any floor or ceiling.
  • Misconception: An offset and an allowance are the same thing. Correct: An allowance is a share of the cap; an offset comes from a project outside it.
  • Misconception: A free allowance costs its holder nothing. Correct: Using it gives up the money it could be sold for, and firms can pass that value on in prices.
  • Misconception: Every carbon market caps total emissions. Correct: China's national ETS and India's scheme set limits per unit of output, so totals can change with production.

Key takeaways

  • A cap-and-trade system limits total emissions from covered sources and issues one allowance for each tonne the cap permits.
  • Firms that cut cheaply sell spare allowances to firms that cannot, so the same cap is met at a lower total cost.
  • A carbon tax fixes the price and lets emissions vary; a cap fixes emissions and lets the price vary.
  • Safeguards such as the EU's Market Stability Reserve, California's floor and ceiling, and RGGI's reserves help keep prices in a range.
  • The EU, China, California with Quebec, and RGGI run major markets; India sets emission intensity targets for 490 entities.
  • Debates centre on effectiveness, carbon leakage, windfall profits from free allowances, offset quality and fairness to poorer exporters.

Test yourself

What does one EU allowance let a firm do?

Emit one tonne of carbon dioxide equivalent; each year, the firm surrenders one allowance per tonne emitted.

In the two-firm example, why does any price between $20 and $60 help both?

Firm A earns more than its $20 cost for each extra tonne cut, and Firm B pays less than its $60 cost of cutting.

Why did the illustrative factory lose €500,000 by falling short?

It paid €500,000 in penalties and still had to surrender 5,000 allowances it could have bought in time for €350,000.

What does the EU's Market Stability Reserve do?

It absorbs part of the surplus when over 833 million allowances circulate, and releases 100 million when fewer than 400 million do.

What is carbon leakage, and how does CBAM respond?

Production moving to places with weaker climate rules. CBAM makes importers of goods such as steel pay for their embedded emissions.

How does India's scheme differ from the EU ETS?

It sets emission intensity targets per unit of output, not a cap on total emissions; entities that beat targets earn certificates to sell.

Go deeper in World 101: Market Failure & Externalities

Write about it

Turn a question from this chapter into a paper.

The Writing Studio has a structure guide, a rubric and citation tools for 15 formats, from essays to research papers. A free account keeps up to five drafts. Learnacy Essential adds feedback from an AI writing coach and submission to The OYI Review.

Publication depends on review and is not guaranteed.