Entrepreneurship in Action, 21-24 Nov, online. Build a working product with AI

Private Sector Enterprise | ICSE Class 9 Commercial Studies Notes

19 min read

On this page

This note covers the meaning and features of the main forms of private sector enterprise: sole proprietorship, partnership, one person company, joint stock company (private and public company), limited liability partnership, and co-operative society, with the Acts that govern each and a comparison of their key features.

What is a private sector enterprise?

A private sector enterprise is a business owned, financed and controlled by private individuals or a group of individuals rather than by the government.

The private sector consists of businesses set up by one person or by groups of people who bring in their own capital, take the risk of the venture and keep the profit earned.

Several forms of organisation are available within the private sector, and each differs in the number of owners it needs, how much capital it can raise, how far the owners are personally liable for the firm's debts, and how long the business can continue.

The forms covered in this note are the sole proprietorship, the partnership, the one person company, the joint stock company (private and public), the limited liability partnership and the co-operative society.

A person starting or expanding a business must weigh the merits and limitations of each form against his or her own requirements, such as the amount of capital needed, the degree of control desired and the willingness to accept risk.

What is a sole proprietorship?

Definition: sole proprietorship. A form of business organisation which is owned, managed and controlled by an individual who is the recipient of all profits and bearer of all risks. The word "sole" means "only" and "proprietor" means "owner".

This is the simplest and most popular form of business, especially suitable for small businesses in their early years, such as a neighbourhood stationery store or a hair saloon offering personalised service.

Features of a sole proprietorship

  • Formation and closure: no separate law governs this form, so there is hardly any legal formality to start or close the business, though a licence may sometimes be needed.
  • Unlimited liability: the owner is personally responsible for all business debts; if the business assets are not enough, personal possessions can be used to repay creditors.
  • Sole risk bearer and profit recipient: the proprietor alone bears the risk of failure and alone enjoys all the profit if the business succeeds.
  • Control: the right to run the business and make all decisions lies entirely with the sole proprietor, without interference from others.
  • No separate entity: the law makes no distinction between the owner and the business.
  • Lack of business continuity: the death, insanity, imprisonment, illness or bankruptcy of the proprietor directly affects the business and may even close it.

What is a partnership?

Definition: partnership. Under the Indian Partnership Act, 1932, partnership is "the relation between persons who have agreed to share the profit of the business carried on by all or any one of them acting for all".

Partnership answers the need for greater capital, varied skills and shared risk that a sole proprietorship cannot always meet. The partnership deed is the written agreement that states the terms and conditions governing the relationship among the partners.

Features of a partnership

  • Formation: governed by the Indian Partnership Act, 1932; it comes into existence through a legal agreement, and the business must be lawful and run with a profit motive.
  • Unlimited liability: partners' personal assets may be used to repay debts if the business assets fall short; partners are jointly and individually liable.
  • Risk bearing: partners share profits and losses in an agreed ratio.
  • Decision making and control: decisions are generally taken with mutual consent of the partners.
  • Continuity: the death, retirement, insolvency or insanity of any partner can end the partnership, though the remaining partners may continue on a new agreement.
  • Number of partners: a minimum of two partners are needed; under section 464 of the Companies Act, 2013 and Rule 10 of the Companies (Miscellaneous) Rules, 2014, the maximum number of partners is currently fifty.
  • Mutual agency: every partner is both an agent and a principal, so the acts of one partner bind all the others.

Partners may be active partners, sleeping partners (who contribute capital but do not take part in management), secret partners, nominal partners, or partners "by estoppel" or "by holding out" who are treated as partners because of the impression they create, even though they may not have contributed capital.

What is a one person company?

Definition: one person company (OPC). A company form that allows a single individual to own and run an incorporated business as its sole shareholder, combining the independence of a sole proprietor with a separate legal identity and limited liability.

A one person company is incorporated under the Companies Act, 2013 and is treated as a kind of private company.

Unlike a sole proprietorship, it has only one member or shareholder, who must also name a nominee at the time of incorporation; this person becomes the member of the company if the original member dies or becomes incapable of entering into a contract.

The company is a separate legal entity from its single owner, which means the owner's personal assets are generally protected if the business runs into debt beyond its own assets, unlike in a sole proprietorship where liability is unlimited.

What is a joint stock company?

Definition: joint stock company. An association of persons formed for carrying out business activities, with a legal status independent of its members; it is described as an artificial person having a separate legal entity, perpetual succession and a common seal.

The company form of organisation is governed by the Companies Act, 2013. As per section 2(20) of the Act, a company means a company incorporated under this Act or any previous company law.

The capital of a company is divided into smaller parts called shares, which can usually be transferred freely from one shareholder to another, except in a private company.

Features of a joint stock company

  • Artificial person: a company can own property, incur debts, borrow money, enter into contracts, and sue and be sued, but it cannot breathe, eat, run or talk as a natural person does.
  • Separate legal entity: from the day of incorporation, a company acquires an identity distinct from its members, and its assets and liabilities are separate from those of its owners.
  • Perpetual succession: a company can be brought to an end only by law, through a procedure called winding up; members may come and go, but the company continues to exist.
  • Limited liability: the liability of members is limited to the extent of the capital they have agreed to contribute. For example, if a shareholder holds 2,000 shares of Rs. 10 each and has paid Rs. 7 per share, his or her liability for the company's debts is limited to the unpaid Rs. 3 per share on 2,000 shares, that is Rs. 6,000, and nothing beyond this.
  • Control: the Board of Directors manages the affairs of the company and is accountable to the shareholders; shareholders do not have the right to be involved in day-to-day running of the business.

Private company and public company

A private company restricts the right of members to transfer its shares, has a minimum of two and a maximum of two hundred members (excluding present and past employees), and does not invite the public to subscribe to its securities; it must use the words "private limited" after its name.

A public company is one that is not a private company: it has a minimum of seven members with no maximum limit, places no restriction on the transfer of shares, and is not prohibited from inviting the public to subscribe to its securities.

BasisPublic companyPrivate company
MembersMinimum 7, maximum unlimitedMinimum 2, maximum 200
Minimum number of directorsThreeTwo
Transfer of sharesNo restrictionRestriction on transfer
Invitation to public to subscribe to sharesCan invite the public to subscribeCannot invite the public to subscribe
Index of membersCompulsoryNot compulsory

What is a limited liability partnership?

Definition: limited liability partnership (LLP). A form of business organisation that combines the flexibility of a partnership with the limited liability and separate legal identity of a company; each partner's liability is limited to the amount he or she has agreed to contribute.

An LLP is a separate legal entity, distinct from its partners, and has perpetual succession, so changes in its partners do not affect its existence or its ability to enter into contracts.

Unlike an ordinary partnership, no partner is liable for the independent or unauthorised actions of other partners, which removes the unlimited mutual liability that burdens a general partnership.

An LLP needs a minimum of two partners, with no maximum limit, and at least two designated partners who are responsible for regulatory compliance; one of the designated partners must be a resident of India. There is no minimum capital requirement to form an LLP.

What is a co-operative society?

Definition: co-operative society. A voluntary association of persons who join together with the motive of the welfare of the members, driven by the need to protect their economic interests in a democratic way.

A co-operative society must be registered under law. After registration, it acquires a distinct legal identity, can enter into contracts, hold property in its own name, and its members' liability is limited to the amount they contribute as capital.

Co-operative societies that operate within a single state are governed by the Co-operative Societies Act of that state, while those operating in more than one state are governed by the Multi-State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002.

Features of a co-operative society

  • Voluntary membership: a person is free to join and free to leave at any time; membership is open to all irrespective of religion, caste and gender.
  • Legal status: registration is compulsory, giving the society a separate identity distinct from its members, so it is unaffected by the entry or exit of members.
  • Limited liability: liability of members is limited to the extent of the capital they have contributed.
  • Control: decisions are taken by an elected managing committee, giving the society a democratic character.
  • Service motive: mutual help and welfare, rather than profit, are the main purpose; any surplus is distributed among members as dividend as per the bye-laws.

The Amul dairy cooperative, based in the village of Anand and begun in December 1946 by a group of farmers seeking to free themselves from intermediaries, illustrates how a co-operative society can grow into a very large enterprise while retaining member ownership and a welfare motive.

What are the Acts that govern these forms?

Each form of private sector enterprise is placed within a legal framework. A sole proprietorship has no separate governing law. A partnership is governed by the Indian Partnership Act, 1932.

A joint stock company, including a one person company, is governed by the Companies Act, 2013. A limited liability partnership is governed by the Limited Liability Partnership Act, 2008.

A co-operative society operating in more than one state is governed by the Multi-State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002, and one operating within a single state is governed by that state's own Co-operative Societies Act.

Merits and limitations of the private sector forms

Advantages of the different forms

  • A sole proprietorship allows quick decision making, keeps information confidential, gives the owner the full benefit of profit, and is easy to form and close.
  • A partnership allows balanced decision making through shared expertise, brings in more funds than a sole proprietor could raise alone, and spreads risk among the partners.
  • A joint stock company offers limited liability, easy transfer of ownership (except in a private company), perpetual existence and professional management.
  • An LLP gives partners limited liability and a separate legal entity while keeping the flexibility of a partnership.
  • A co-operative society gives members equal voting rights regardless of their capital contribution, limited liability, and support from the government in the form of low taxes and subsidies.

Limitations of the different forms

  • A sole proprietorship has limited resources, unlimited liability, and limited managerial ability since one person must handle every function.
  • A partnership suffers from unlimited liability, possible conflicts between partners, and lack of continuity if a partner leaves, dies or becomes insolvent.
  • A joint stock company is complex and costly to form, cannot keep its operations fully secret, and may suffer delay in decision making because of its layered management.
  • A co-operative society has limited resources because members' means are limited, and it can find it hard to attract professional managers.
FormMinimum membersLiabilitySeparate legal entity
Sole proprietorship1UnlimitedNo
Partnership2Unlimited and jointNo
One person company1 (with a nominee)LimitedYes
Limited liability partnership2 (no maximum)Limited to agreed contributionYes
Co-operative societyAt least 10 adultsLimited to capital contributedYes
Private company2 (maximum 200)LimitedYes
Public company7 (no maximum)LimitedYes

Going beyond the syllabus

The government has also been willing to allow private forms limited liability without the full cost of forming a public company, which is why the one person company and the limited liability partnership were added to Indian business law (the Limited Liability Partnership Act, 2008 and the Companies Act, 2013) well after the sole proprietorship, partnership, joint stock company and co-operative society had long existed.

Both forms try to combine the simplicity that small owners want with the protection of personal assets that only a separate legal entity can give.

Glossary

  • Sole proprietorship: a business owned, managed and controlled by a single individual who bears all the risk and takes all the profit.
  • Unlimited liability: a situation where the owner's personal assets can be used to pay business debts if business assets are insufficient.
  • Partnership deed: the written agreement stating the terms and conditions that govern a partnership.
  • Mutual agency: the principle that every partner is both an agent and a principal, so one partner's acts bind all the others.
  • One person company: a company incorporated under the Companies Act, 2013 with a single shareholder and a named nominee.
  • Nominee: the person named by the sole member of a one person company who becomes its member if the original member dies or is incapacitated.
  • Joint stock company: an artificial person formed to carry on business, with a legal status separate from its members.
  • Perpetual succession: the continued existence of a company regardless of changes in its membership, ending only through winding up.
  • Private company: a company that restricts share transfer, has 2 to 200 members and cannot invite the public to subscribe to its securities.
  • Public company: a company with a minimum of 7 members, no maximum, that may invite the public to subscribe to its securities.
  • Limited liability partnership: a form combining partnership flexibility with a separate legal entity and liability limited to each partner's agreed contribution.
  • Designated partner: a partner in an LLP responsible for regulatory compliance, of whom at least one must be a resident of India.
  • Co-operative society: a voluntary association of persons who join together for the welfare and economic protection of its members.
  • Managing committee: the elected body of members that takes decisions in a co-operative society.
  • Separate legal entity: a status under which the business is recognised by law as distinct from its owners, who are therefore protected from unlimited personal liability.

Common errors and misconceptions

  • Misconception: a sole proprietorship and a one person company are the same thing. Correct: a sole proprietorship has no separate legal identity and unlimited liability, while a one person company is a separate legal entity under the Companies Act, 2013 with limited liability.
  • Misconception: all partners in a partnership have limited liability. Correct: under the Indian Partnership Act, 1932, partners have unlimited and joint liability; owners who want limited liability with a partnership's flexibility choose a different form, the limited liability partnership.
  • Misconception: a private company can invite the general public to buy its shares. Correct: a private company is specifically prohibited from inviting the public to subscribe to its securities; only a public company can do so.
  • Misconception: a co-operative society is run for profit like a company. Correct: a co-operative society is driven by a service and welfare motive, though any surplus generated is distributed among members as dividend.
  • Misconception: in an LLP, one partner can be made liable for another partner's independent wrongdoing. Correct: no partner in an LLP is liable for the unauthorised acts of another partner, unlike in an ordinary partnership.
  • Misconception: a one person company has no director other than its single shareholder. Correct: while there is only one shareholder, the company still requires a nominee and can appoint directors to run it.
  • Misconception: membership of a co-operative society is restricted to a particular group. Correct: membership is voluntary and open to all irrespective of religion, caste and gender.

Exam-style questions with model answers

Q1. Define sole proprietorship. [2 marks]
  1. Sole proprietorship is a form of business owned, managed and controlled by an individual.
  2. The proprietor receives all the profits and bears all the risks of the business.
Q2. State two features of a partnership. [2 marks]
  1. A partnership is formed through a legal agreement among two or more partners, governed by the Indian Partnership Act, 1932.
  2. Partners have unlimited and joint liability for the debts of the firm.
Q3. Distinguish between a private company and a public company on the basis of membership and share transfer. [4 marks]
  1. A private company has a minimum of 2 members and a maximum of 200, while a public company has a minimum of 7 members and no maximum limit.
  2. A private company restricts the right of its members to transfer shares, while a public company places no restriction on the transfer of shares.
Q4. Explain the meaning and features of a one person company. [4 marks]
  1. A one person company is incorporated under the Companies Act, 2013 and allows a single individual to own and run an incorporated business.
  2. It has only one member or shareholder, unlike an ordinary company which needs at least two or seven members.
  3. The sole member must name a nominee at incorporation, who becomes the member if the original member dies or becomes incapacitated.
  4. It is a separate legal entity, so the owner's personal assets are generally protected from the company's debts.
Q5. What is a limited liability partnership? State two of its features. [3 marks]
  1. A limited liability partnership is a form that combines the flexibility of a partnership with the limited liability and separate legal identity of a company.
  2. Each partner's liability is limited to the amount he or she has agreed to contribute.
  3. No partner is liable for the independent or unauthorised acts of another partner.
Q6. Explain the meaning and any four features of a co-operative society. [6 marks]
  1. A co-operative society is a voluntary association of persons who join together with the motive of welfare of the members, protecting their economic interests in a democratic way.
  2. Membership is voluntary: a person is free to join and free to leave at any time, and membership is open to all irrespective of religion, caste and gender.
  3. Registration is compulsory, which gives the society a legal status distinct from its members, so it can hold property and enter contracts in its own name.
  4. Liability of members is limited to the extent of the capital they have contributed as members.
  5. Control lies with an elected managing committee, giving the society a democratic character.
  6. The society is run on a service motive rather than a profit motive, and any surplus is distributed among members as dividend.
Q7. Compare a sole proprietorship and a partnership on the basis of number of owners, liability and continuity. [4 marks]
  1. A sole proprietorship has only one owner, whereas a partnership has a minimum of two partners.
  2. Both forms have unlimited liability, but in a partnership the liability is also joint, meaning each partner can be held responsible for the whole debt.
  3. A sole proprietorship ends on the death, insanity or insolvency of the single owner, directly closing the business.
  4. A partnership can also end on the death, retirement or insolvency of any one partner, though the remaining partners may continue the business under a new agreement.
Q8. Name the Act that governs partnerships in India and state one provision of this Act mentioned for partnerships. [2 marks]
  1. Partnerships in India are governed by the Indian Partnership Act, 1932.
  2. The Act defines partnership as the relation between persons who agree to share the profit of a business carried on by all or any one of them acting for all.

Key takeaways

  • A sole proprietorship is owned by one person who takes all the profit and bears unlimited personal liability.
  • A partnership is formed by agreement under the Indian Partnership Act, 1932, with partners sharing unlimited and joint liability.
  • A one person company, incorporated under the Companies Act, 2013, gives a single owner limited liability through a separate legal entity, with a nominee named at incorporation.
  • A joint stock company is an artificial person with perpetual succession, a common seal, and liability limited to unpaid share capital.
  • A private company restricts share transfer and has 2 to 200 members; a public company has at least 7 members and can invite the public to subscribe.
  • A limited liability partnership combines the flexibility of a partnership with limited liability and a separate legal identity of its own.
  • A co-operative society is a voluntary, democratically run association with limited liability, working on a service rather than profit motive.
  • The form of organisation chosen depends on the capital needed, the liability the owners are willing to bear, and how long the business is expected to continue.

Test yourself

What does "sole" mean in sole proprietorship?

"Sole" means "only", showing that the business has a single owner who is the only proprietor.

Which Act governs partnerships in India?

The Indian Partnership Act, 1932 governs partnerships in India.

What is the minimum and maximum membership of a private company?

A private company must have a minimum of 2 members and a maximum of 200 members, excluding present and past employees.

Who must a sole member of a one person company name at incorporation?

The sole member must name a nominee, who becomes the member if the original member dies or becomes incapable of entering into a contract.

How is liability limited in a limited liability partnership?

Each partner's liability in an LLP is limited to the amount he or she has agreed to contribute to the firm.

What motive dominates the working of a co-operative society?

A co-operative society is driven by a service motive, emphasising mutual help and welfare rather than profit.

What is perpetual succession?

Perpetual succession means a company continues to exist regardless of changes in its membership, ending only through winding up by law.

Can a private company invite the public to buy its shares?

No, a private company cannot invite the public to subscribe to its securities; only a public company can do so.

Write about it

Turn a question from this chapter into a paper.

The Writing Studio has a structure guide, a rubric and citation tools for 15 formats, from essays to research papers. A free account keeps up to five drafts. Learnacy Essential adds feedback from an AI writing coach and submission to The OYI Review.

Publication depends on review and is not guaranteed.