Public sector enterprise | ICSE Class 9 Commercial Studies Notes
On this page
This note covers the meaning of the public sector and how it differs from the private sector, and the three forms in which the government organises its public sector enterprises: departmental undertakings, public corporations and government companies, with their meaning and examples.
What is the public sector?
A country's economy can be divided into two broad parts. The private sector consists of businesses owned by individuals or groups of individuals, such as sole proprietorships, partnerships, joint Hindu family businesses, cooperatives and companies.
The public sector consists of various organisations owned and managed by the government. These organisations may be partly or wholly owned by the central or state government.
They may be part of a ministry, or they may come into existence through a Special Act of Parliament.
Because both private and government enterprises are allowed to operate side by side, the economy is described as a mixed economy. Through public sector enterprises, the government participates directly in the economic activities of the country.
Definition: Public sector enterprise. A business organisation owned and managed (wholly or partly) by the central or state government, characterised by public ownership, the use of public funds, and public accountability to the people through Parliament.
A public enterprise may take any one of three forms, depending on the nature of its operations and its relationship with the government: a departmental undertaking, a public corporation, or a government company.
The right choice of form depends on the requirements of the particular enterprise, such as how much independence from ministry control it needs and how it is to be funded.
What is a departmental undertaking?
A departmental undertaking is the oldest and most traditional form of organising a public enterprise. It is established as a department of a ministry and is treated as part of, or an extension of, the ministry itself.
The government functions through the department, and the department's activities are an integral part of the functioning of the government. It is not set up as an autonomous or independent institution and so is not an independent legal entity.
Definition: Departmental undertaking. A public enterprise organised as a department of a ministry, with no separate legal identity, whose employees are government servants and whose funds and revenue flow directly through the government treasury.
In India, two well-known departmental undertakings are the Railways, wholly owned and managed by the Government of India, and the Post and Telegraph Department, whose post offices are found in towns across the country; its postal work is now carried out by the Department of Posts.
Both are run as departments of the government rather than as separate companies, and their staff are government servants. The Railways and the Post and Telegraph Department are the standard examples to quote when a question asks for examples of this form.
What is a public corporation?
A public corporation, also called a statutory corporation, is a public enterprise brought into existence by a Special Act of Parliament. The Act defines its powers and functions, and the rules governing its employees and its relationship with government departments.
It is a corporate body created by the legislature, with defined powers, and is financially independent, with clear control over a specified area or type of commercial activity.
It has the power of government behind it, combined with a considerable amount of the operating flexibility enjoyed by private enterprises.
Definition: Public corporation. A public enterprise created by a Special Act of Parliament, which is a corporate body wholly owned by the state, can sue and be sued in its own name, and is financially independent of the government budget.
Well-known Indian public corporations include the Life Insurance Corporation (LIC), set up under the Life Insurance Corporation Act, 1956, and the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), set up under the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934. In each case, the separate Act gives the corporation its own legal identity and its own rules of finance and employment, distinct from an ordinary government department. Some of LIC's shares have been sold to the public since 2022, but the government remains its main owner and it is still governed by its own Act.
What is a government company?
A government company is established under the Companies Act, 2013 and is registered and governed by the provisions of that Act. It is set up for purely business purposes and, in true spirit, is meant to compete with companies in the private sector.
Definition: Government company. Under section 2(45) of the Companies Act, 2013, a government company means any company in which not less than 51 per cent of the paid-up capital is held by the central government, or by any state government, or partly by the central government and partly by one or more state governments, and includes a company which is a subsidiary of such a government company.
The shares of a government company are purchased in the name of the President of India. Because the government is the major shareholder and exercises control over its management, such companies are called government companies.
In India, two government companies that have played a role in expanding exports are STC (State Trading Corporation) and MMTC.
How do the three forms differ in their meaning?
The three forms can be told apart by how each one comes into being and by what legal identity it receives. A departmental undertaking is simply a department of a ministry, while a public corporation is created by a Special Act of Parliament and a government company is registered under the Companies Act, 2013.
| Point of difference | Departmental undertaking | Public corporation | Government company |
|---|---|---|---|
| How it is formed | As a department of a ministry | By a Special Act of Parliament | Registered under the Companies Act, 2013 |
| Legal entity | Not a separate legal entity | Separate legal entity; can sue and be sued | Separate legal entity; can sue and be sued |
| Example | Railways, Post and Telegraph Department | LIC, RBI | STC, MMTC |
The features, merits and limitations of each form are set out in the next section.
Going beyond the syllabus
These ideas extend the unit and are not needed for the questions on it.
What are the features of a departmental undertaking?
- Its funding comes directly from the government treasury as an annual appropriation from the budget, and the revenue it earns is also paid back into the treasury.
- It is subject to the same accounting and audit controls as other government activities.
- Its employees are government servants, recruited on the same conditions of service as other government staff, and are often headed by IAS officers who are transferable between ministries.
- It is generally considered a major subdivision of the government department and is subject to the direct control of the ministry.
- It is accountable to the ministry, since its management is directly under the concerned ministry.
What are the features of a public corporation?
- It is set up under an Act of Parliament, which defines its objects, powers and privileges.
- It is wholly owned by the state; the government has ultimate financial responsibility, can appropriate its profits and must bear its losses.
- It is a body corporate and can sue and be sued, enter into contracts, and acquire property in its own name.
- It is usually independently financed, raising funds by borrowing from the government or the public, or from revenue earned by selling goods and services.
- It is not subject to the same accounting and audit procedures as government departments, and it is not part of the central budget.
- Its employees are not government servants and are not governed by government service rules; their conditions of service come from the Act itself, though some officers may be sent on deputation from government departments.
What are the features of a government company?
- It is created under the Companies Act, 2013, or an earlier company law.
- It can file a suit in a court of law against a third party, and can itself be sued.
- It can enter into a contract and acquire property in its own name.
- Its management is regulated by the provisions of the Companies Act, like any other public limited company.
- Its employees are appointed under its own rules, contained in the company's Memorandum and Articles of Association, the main documents setting out the company's objects and rules.
- It is exempt from the usual government accounting and audit rules; instead, an auditor is appointed by the central government, and the Annual Report is placed before Parliament or the State Legislature.
- It obtains funds from government shareholding, from other private shareholders, and is also permitted to raise funds from the capital market.
What are the merits and limitations of these three forms?
Each form has advantages suited to a different purpose. Departmental undertakings allow Parliament to exercise effective control, ensure a high degree of public accountability, send revenue straight to the treasury, and are best suited where national security is concerned, since they are under the direct supervision of the ministry.
Public corporations enjoy independence and operational flexibility, are free from undesirable government interference in day-to-day finance, frame their own policies within the powers given by the Act, and combine the power of government with the initiative of private enterprise.
Government companies can be set up simply by meeting the requirements of the Companies Act (a separate Act of Parliament is not needed), have a separate legal entity apart from the government, enjoy autonomy in management decisions, and, by supplying goods and services at reasonable prices, help to curb unhealthy business practices.
Departmental undertakings lack flexibility, cannot take independent decisions without ministry approval (which causes delay), suffer from red tapism, political interference, and tend to be insensitive to consumer needs.
Public corporations, despite their formal independence, are subject to many rules in practice, suffer from government and political interference in major decisions, and may face corruption where they deal with the public; government-appointed advisers on their boards can curb their freedom to contract.
Government companies, where the government is the sole shareholder in some of the companies, may find that the provisions of the Companies Act have little practical relevance, are not directly answerable to Parliament in the way a true public body is, and may have their real purpose as an independent business defeated because management effectively rests with the government.
How has the role of the public sector changed since Independence?
The role of the public sector in India has changed considerably since Independence. At first, public sector enterprises were expected to build up infrastructure for other sectors of the economy and invest in key areas, since the private sector was unwilling to invest in projects requiring heavy investment and long gestation periods, such as steel, power generation and railways.
Four major steel plants were deliberately set up in backward areas to accelerate economic development, provide employment and develop ancillary industries, as part of the government's objective of achieving regional balance across India. Public sector companies involved in heavy engineering were also established to help with import substitution, and companies such as STC and MMTC were set up to expand the country's exports.
In the post-1990s period, new economic policies emphasised liberalisation, privatisation and globalisation, and the public sector was no longer expected to play a passive role but to actively compete with private sector companies in the same industry. The 1991 industrial policy introduced four major reforms: restructuring and reviving potentially viable public sector undertakings, closing down those that could not be revived, bringing down government equity in non-strategic undertakings, and protecting the interests of workers.
Loss-making units were referred to the Board for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction (BIFR) to decide whether they should be restructured or closed, and a National Renewal Fund was set up to retrain or redeploy retrenched labour. The number of industries reserved exclusively for the public sector was reduced from seventeen in 1956 to eight in 1991 and then to just three (atomic energy, arms, and rail transport) by 2001, allowing the private sector to compete in nearly every other area, alongside disinvestment of government shares in several public sector enterprises.
Glossary
- Public sector: organisations owned and managed, wholly or partly, by the central or state government.
- Private sector: businesses owned by individuals or groups of individuals rather than by the government.
- Mixed economy: an economy in which both private and government enterprises are allowed to operate.
- Departmental undertaking: a public enterprise run as a department of a ministry, with no separate legal identity.
- Public corporation: a public enterprise created by a Special Act of Parliament, with defined powers and financial independence.
- Government company: a company registered under the Companies Act, 2013, in which not less than 51 per cent of paid-up capital is held by the government.
- Public accountability: the obligation of a public enterprise to answer to the public, usually through Parliament.
- Paid-up capital: the part of a company's issued share capital that shareholders have actually paid for.
- Red tapism: excessive adherence to official rules and procedure, which causes delay in decision-making.
- Legal entity: a body recognised in law as capable of owning property and being sued in its own name.
- Treasury: the government's central fund into which revenue is paid and from which expenditure is met.
- IAS officers: members of the Indian Administrative Service who often head departmental undertakings and can be transferred between ministries.
- Special Act: a law passed by Parliament specifically to create and govern a particular public corporation.
- Articles of Association: the document containing the rules for the internal management of a company.
- Disinvestment: the sale by the government of its shares in a public sector enterprise to the private sector or the public.
Common errors and misconceptions
- Misconception: A departmental undertaking is a separate legal entity like a company. Correct: It has no separate legal identity; it is simply part of the ministry.
- Misconception: All public sector employees are government servants. Correct: Only employees of departmental undertakings are government servants; employees of public corporations and government companies are not.
- Misconception: A public corporation is created under the Companies Act. Correct: A public corporation is created by a Special Act of Parliament; it is a government company that is created under the Companies Act, 2013.
- Misconception: A government company needs 100 per cent government ownership. Correct: It needs only not less than 51 per cent of paid-up capital held by the government (centrally, by a state, or jointly).
- Misconception: Public corporations must follow the same budget and audit procedures as government departments. Correct: They are financially independent and are not part of the central budget or subject to the same accounting controls.
- Misconception: Revenue of a public corporation goes to the treasury, as with a departmental undertaking. Correct: A public corporation keeps and uses its own revenue; only a departmental undertaking pays its revenue into the treasury.
- Misconception: Government companies are completely free of government control because they are registered under the Companies Act. Correct: Since the government holds majority shares, real management decisions often still rest with the government.
Exam-style questions with model answers
Q1. Define a departmental undertaking. [2 marks]
- A departmental undertaking is a public enterprise organised as a department of a ministry and treated as part of the ministry itself, with no separate legal identity.
- It is funded directly from the government treasury, the revenue it earns is paid back into the treasury, and its employees are government servants.
Q2. Name two examples of departmental undertakings and state why each is treated as part of a ministry. [2 marks]
- Railways is a departmental undertaking because it is wholly owned and managed by the government and its staff are government servants under the concerned ministry.
- The Post and Telegraph Department is a departmental undertaking because it is run as a department of a ministry, with no separate legal identity of its own.
Q3. Explain the meaning of a public corporation and give two examples. [3 marks]
- A public corporation, also called a statutory corporation, is a public enterprise brought into existence by a Special Act of Parliament, which defines its powers, functions and the rules for its employees.
- It is a corporate body owned by the state that can sue and be sued in its own name and is financially independent of the government budget.
- Two examples are the Life Insurance Corporation (LIC), set up under the Life Insurance Corporation Act, 1956, and the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), set up under the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934.
Q4. State the definition of a government company given under the Companies Act, 2013. [4 marks]
- A government company is any company in which not less than 51 per cent of the paid-up capital is held by the central government.
- Or it is held by any state government.
- Or it is held partly by the central government and partly by one or more state governments.
- It also includes any company that is a subsidiary of such a government company.
Q5. Give two examples of government companies set up for foreign trade and describe the role each has played for India. [2 marks]
- STC, the State Trading Corporation, is a government company that has helped to expand India's exports of various goods.
- MMTC is a government company that has also played a role in expanding India's exports and foreign trade.
Q6. Distinguish between a departmental undertaking and a public corporation on the basis of legal status and funding. [4 marks]
- A departmental undertaking has no separate legal entity, being part of the ministry, whereas a public corporation is a separate body corporate that can sue and be sued in its own name.
- A departmental undertaking is funded by an annual appropriation from the government budget, and its revenue is paid into the treasury.
- A public corporation is independently financed through borrowings or its own revenue from the sale of goods and services.
- A public corporation is not tied to the central budget, while a departmental undertaking is subject to the same budget and audit controls as other government activities.
Q7. Explain the meaning of a public sector enterprise and name the three forms it may take, with one example of each. [4 marks]
- A public sector enterprise is a business organisation owned and managed, wholly or partly, by the central or state government, through which the government takes part in the economic activities of the country.
- A departmental undertaking is run as a department of a ministry, with no separate legal identity; an example is the Railways.
- A public corporation is created by a Special Act of Parliament as a separate body corporate; an example is the Life Insurance Corporation (LIC).
- A government company is registered under the Companies Act, 2013, with not less than 51 per cent of its paid-up capital held by the government; an example is STC (State Trading Corporation).
Q8. Describe the meaning and two examples of a government company, and explain why such companies are called government companies. [5 marks]
- A government company is established under the Companies Act, 2013, in which not less than 51 per cent of the paid-up capital is held by the central or a state government, or partly by both.
- It is set up for purely business purposes and competes with private sector companies in true spirit.
- Its shares are purchased in the name of the President of India, and it is governed like any other public limited company.
- Examples named are STC and MMTC, which have played a role in expanding exports.
- Such companies are called government companies because the government is the major shareholder and exercises control over their management.
Key takeaways
- The public sector consists of enterprises owned and managed, wholly or partly, by the central or state government.
- A public enterprise may be organised as a departmental undertaking, a public corporation, or a government company.
- A departmental undertaking is part of a ministry, has no separate legal identity, and its employees are government servants.
- Railways and the Post and Telegraph Department are examples of departmental undertakings.
- A public corporation is created by a Special Act of Parliament and is a financially independent body corporate.
- LIC and RBI are examples of public corporations set up by their own Acts.
- A government company is registered under the Companies Act, 2013, with at least 51 per cent paid-up capital held by the government.
- STC and MMTC are examples of government companies named for their role in exports.
- Each form has its own merits and limitations, which affect how far it can act with flexibility and how closely the government controls it.
Test yourself
What is meant by the public sector?
Organisations owned and managed, wholly or partly, by the central or state government, which participate in the economic activities of the country.
Name the three forms in which a public sector enterprise may be organised.
Departmental undertaking, public corporation, and government company.
Give one example each of a departmental undertaking and a government company.
Railways is an example of a departmental undertaking; STC (State Trading Corporation) is an example of a government company.
Under which Act is a government company registered, and what minimum share of paid-up capital must the government hold?
It is registered under the Companies Act, 2013, and the government must hold not less than 51 per cent of the paid-up capital.
How is a public corporation brought into existence?
By a Special Act of Parliament, which defines its powers, functions and rules for its employees.
Why are a departmental undertaking's employees called government servants?
Because the undertaking is simply part of a ministry, so its staff follow the same recruitment and service rules as other government employees.
Name two public corporations and the Acts under which they were set up.
The Life Insurance Corporation (LIC), set up under the Life Insurance Corporation Act, 1956, and the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), set up under the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934.
Write about it
Turn a question from this chapter into a paper.
The Writing Studio has a structure guide, a rubric and citation tools for 15 formats, from essays to research papers. A free account keeps up to five drafts. Learnacy Essential adds feedback from an AI writing coach and submission to The OYI Review.
Publication depends on review and is not guaranteed.
