The Midnight Visitor | CBSE Class 10 English Notes
On this page
Who wrote this story and what is it about?
Robert Arthur is the author of "The Midnight Visitor". A short introduction to the chapter frames the plot like this: Ausable, a secret agent, is expecting a very important report, and another agent, Max, threatens him with a pistol, demanding it. The story asks whether Ausable can outwit him.
The story is told mostly through the eyes of Fowler, a young writer who wants to meet a "real" secret agent and is startled by what he actually finds: a fat, wheezing man in a small, "gloomy" Paris hotel room.
The humour and suspense of the story come from this contrast between Fowler's expectations of spies and the undramatic, clever reality of Ausable.
Much of the plot turns on a single invented detail, a balcony that does not exist, and on Ausable's calm, quick-thinking response to an armed intruder.
The story rewards readers who notice how carefully each small detail, the window, the knock at the door, the waiter with the tray, is placed to build towards the twist ending.
What happens in the story, part by part?
Fowler meets the "secret agent"
Fowler follows Ausable down "the musty corridor of the gloomy French hotel" to his room on the sixth and top floor.
Ausable does not fit any description of a secret agent Fowler had ever read: he is "very fat" and still speaks with the American accent he brought from Boston twenty years earlier.
Ausable teases Fowler, saying he is disappointed because he expected "mysterious figures in the night, the crack of pistols, drugs in the wine" but instead got a dull evening and a "prosaic telephone call".
Ausable promises that a very important paper, one for which "several men and women have risked their lives", is coming to him that night.
Max is waiting with a pistol
As Ausable switches on the light, Fowler gets his "first authentic thrill of the day": a man named Max, holding a small automatic pistol, is standing halfway across the room.
Max has a slender build with features suggesting "the crafty, pointed countenance of a fox", but nothing about him, apart from the gun, seems especially menacing.
Max explains that he wants the report concerning "some new missiles" because, he says, "it will be safer in my hands than in yours".
Ausable invents the balcony
Ausable complains loudly that Max must have climbed in through "that nuisance of a balcony" outside his window, and that this is the second time in a month someone has entered that way.
Max corrects him, saying he used a passkey, not a balcony, and did not even know one existed.
Ausable explains, for Fowler's benefit as much as Max's, that his room was once part of a larger suite, and the next room had a balcony that "extends under my window now", reachable from an empty room two doors down.
Max orders Fowler to sit and says they have "a wait of half an hour".
The knock at the door
A sudden knocking interrupts them. Ausable calmly says it will be the police, whom he had asked to check on him because the paper he awaited was so important.
Max, his face "black with anger", backs towards the window, swings a leg over the sill, and threatens to shoot if the visitors are not sent away, saying he will wait on the balcony.
As the knocking grows louder and a voice calls "Mr Ausable! Mr Ausable!", Max swings his other leg over the sill, pushes himself free, and drops, screaming "shrilly" as he falls, since there is no balcony there to catch him.
The twist: there was no balcony
The door opens, but it is only a waiter named Henry with a tray, a bottle and two glasses, delivering a drink Ausable had ordered earlier. There were never any police.
White-faced, Fowler asks what will happen when the man on the balcony returns, and Ausable quietly reveals the truth: "No, he won't return. You see, my young friend, there is no balcony."
Who are the characters in the story?
Ausable
Ausable is the secret agent at the centre of the story. Physically, he is "sloppy" and fat, with an American accent he has kept for twenty years in Paris, and he speaks French and German only "passably".
He is unlike any storybook spy: no pistols, no dark-eyed beauties, only a "prosaic telephone call".
Yet under the real threat of Max's gun, Ausable stays completely calm, invents a convincing story about a balcony that does not exist, and uses the ordinary interruption of a waiter's knock to trick Max into leaping towards a balcony that is pure fiction.
His presence of mind, the ability to think quickly and act wisely under danger and surprise, is the engine of the whole plot.
Max
Max is the rival secret agent who breaks into Ausable's room with a small automatic pistol to steal the report about "some new missiles".
His face has "the crafty, pointed countenance of a fox", suggesting slyness, but the narrator notes that "aside from the gun" there is "nothing especially menacing" about him.
Max is confident enough to correct Ausable's story about the balcony, pointing out he actually used a passkey, but this very confidence, and his failure to question Ausable's claim that a balcony exists, becomes his undoing when he climbs out of the window in panic at the knocking on the door.
Fowler
Fowler is a young, romantic writer who wanted to meet a secret agent and is the story's narrator-like observer.
He begins the evening "let down" by Ausable's unglamorous appearance, then gets his "first authentic thrill of the day" when he sees Max's pistol.
Throughout the tense wait, Fowler is "standing stiffly", and by the end he is "white-faced" and stammering, a stand-in for the reader's own surprise at how the story resolves.
Henry
Henry is the hotel waiter whose ordinary knock at the door, bringing a drink Ausable had ordered earlier, becomes the trigger for Max's panic. Henry has no idea of the drama his simple delivery sets off; his very ordinariness is what makes Ausable's trick work.
What themes does the story explore?
Presence of mind in a crisis
The central theme is Ausable's "presence of mind", his ability to "think quickly, and act calmly and wisely" when an armed stranger confronts him.
Instead of panicking, he invents the balcony story on the spot, or at least uses it with total conviction, turning Max's own fear against him when the knock comes.
Appearance versus reality
The story repeatedly undercuts expectations. Ausable "did not fit any description of a secret agent" that Fowler had read.
Max looks like a fox but is not especially menacing; the dramatic knock at the door turns out to be only a waiter with a drink.
Reality, the story suggests, is far less theatrical than fiction, yet still full of real danger and real cleverness.
The power of a convincing story
Ausable's invented balcony works because of its careful, matter-of-fact detail: a nuisance the management has failed to fix, a door to an empty room, a balcony that "extends under my window now".
The theme here is that a lie told with precise, ordinary-sounding detail is more believable than any dramatic claim.
Suspense built from ordinary objects
A window, a knock, a tray of drinks, none of these are inherently dramatic, yet the story uses them to build and then release tension. This shows how suspense in storytelling does not need obvious danger signs; it can come from how a character responds to perfectly mundane events.
What are the key quotations from the story?
"You are disappointed," Ausable said. "You were told that I was a secret agent, a spy, dealing in espionage and danger. You wished to meet me because you are a writer, young and romantic. You envisioned mysterious figures in the night, the crack of pistols, drugs in the wine."
Ausable, teasing Fowler early in the story
"Balcony?" Max said. "No, a passkey. I did not know about the balcony."
Max, explaining how he entered the room
"It's not my balcony," Ausable said with extreme irritation. "It belongs to the next apartment."
Ausable, inventing the detail that convinces Max
"Send them away!" he warned. "I will wait on the balcony."
Max, panicking at the knock on the door
"There were no police," Ausable sighed. "Only Henry, whom I was expecting."
Ausable, revealing the truth to Fowler
"You see, my young friend, there is no balcony."
Ausable, the final twist of the story
What are the answers to the textbook questions?
How is Ausable different from other secret agents?
Ausable does not fit any description of a secret agent Fowler had ever read: he is "very fat", "sloppy", and still carries the American accent he brought to Paris twenty years ago.
Instead of mysterious figures and the "crack of pistols", his evening involves a dull music hall visit and a plain telephone call. His strength is not in appearance but in calm, quick thinking under real danger.
Who is Fowler and what is his first authentic thrill of the day?
Fowler is a young, romantic writer who wanted to meet Ausable because he imagined secret agents as dramatic figures. His "first authentic thrill of the day" comes when the light is switched on and he sees Max standing across the room with "a small automatic pistol in his hand".
How has Max got in, and how does Ausable say he got in?
Max says he entered using a passkey and did not know about any balcony. Ausable, however, insists loudly that Max must have climbed in through "that nuisance of a balcony" that extends under his window from the empty room two doors down, blaming the hotel management for not blocking it off.
How does Ausable make Max believe there is a balcony, and what makes the story convincing?
Ausable describes the balcony with precise, ordinary detail: it belonged to the room next door when his room was part of a larger suite, it now extends under his window, and someone else supposedly used it "last month" because the management never fixed the gap.
These small, unglamorous, specific details, rather than anything dramatic, make the invented balcony sound entirely believable.
When did Ausable think up his plan?
The text does not state outright when Ausable formed his plan, so readers must infer it from the story's sequence.
He mentions the balcony as soon as he sees Max, suggesting he may have begun building the lie immediately; he then uses the knock he knew was coming: a waiter was already due to bring him a drink he had ordered earlier that evening, and he turns that real, prearranged knock into evidence for Max by falsely claiming it will be the police checking on him, showing he had prepared at least this one element of his defence before Max ever appeared, and he adapted the rest in the moment Max panicked.
What does Ausable's presence of mind show us?
The story treats presence of mind as the ability to stay calm and think clearly during danger and surprise.
Ausable never loses his composure when confronted by Max's pistol; he keeps talking, invents convincing detail, and times his trick to the exact moment a real knock at the door arrives, turning an ordinary event into the means of resolving a dangerous situation without any violence of his own.
How does Ausable use presence of mind to outwit Max?
Ausable's trick rests on timing as much as invention. He already knows, from an earlier arrangement, that Henry the waiter will knock at a set time bringing a drink.
He uses this certainty to build his plan: first he tells Max that the knock, whenever it comes, will be the police checking on him, a claim Max has no way to disprove.
He had also already planted, as soon as he saw Max, the detailed and perfectly ordinary story of a balcony that supposedly runs under his window from the room next door.
By the time the knock actually happens, Max has no reason to doubt either claim: the balcony "exists" in his mind, and the knock "must" be the police.
Faced with what he believes is a police visit, Max chooses to escape onto the balcony rather than be caught inside the room with a drawn pistol.
He swings his legs over the sill in full view of Ausable and Fowler, and falls, screaming, because the balcony is not there.
Ausable never needs to fight, shout, or even raise his voice; his only tools are patience, a calm manner, and one carefully placed lie.
Why is the setting of a Paris hotel room important to the story?
The entire story takes place inside a single, ordinary setting: Ausable's small room on "the sixth and top floor" of "the gloomy French hotel". This is deliberately unglamorous.
Fowler notices at once that it is "scarcely a setting for a romantic adventure", setting up the contrast between what Fowler expects of spy stories and what he actually experiences.
The room's history matters directly to the plot. Ausable explains that it "used to be part of a large unit", with the next room once serving as the living room and having its own balcony.
This detail is what allows Ausable's lie to sound plausible: he is not inventing an impossible balcony out of nothing, he is describing a layout that genuinely could exist in an old hotel that has been divided into smaller rooms.
The single window, pressed against by "the night" outside, becomes the focus of tension once Max retreats towards it.
Because the room has only one door and one window, and because Fowler can see exactly where Max goes, the setting keeps the danger contained and visible, which is essential for the suspense of the climax to work on the reader as well as on Max.
What makes the ending of the story surprising?
The story's final twist works because of how carefully it has been prepared without being obvious.
Ausable repeatedly refers to the balcony as a known nuisance, something the hotel management had "promised to block off" but never did, so that by the time Max climbs out, both Max and the reader have accepted it as real.
When the knocking comes and Max demands that Ausable "send them away", the reader expects a confrontation with the police.
Instead, the door opens on Henry, a waiter with a tray, a bottle and two glasses, delivering a drink that had been ordered earlier. This deflation of expected danger into something completely harmless is itself part of the surprise.
The true shock, however, is reserved for Ausable's final line: "there is no balcony." The story never shows the balcony to the reader directly; it only reports Ausable's words about it, which means the twist depends entirely on trusting a narrator figure who has, in fact, been lying throughout.
This makes the ending satisfying because it rewards readers who paid attention to how insistently, and how early, Ausable introduced the balcony story.
Glossary
- Romantic — imaginative; having a fantastic, exaggerated view of reality rather than a plain, practical one
- Passably — just well enough to get by; in a tolerably good way, though not perfectly
- Espionage — the practice of spying, or of using secret agents to gather another country's information
- Sloppy — (here) carelessly dressed, with no attention paid to neatness or appearance
- Prosaic — ordinary and unexciting; lacking any sense of drama, romance or adventure
- Chuckled — laughed quietly to himself, without opening his mouth wide or making much noise
- Wheezed — spoke while breathing noisily and heavily, as a very fat or unfit person might
- Missiles — weapons that are directed towards their target by remote control or automatically, without a pilot
- Shrilly — in a high-pitched, piercing way, as Max screams once while falling from the window
- Passkey — a key that can open several different locks, used here by Max to enter Ausable's room
- Disillusioned — made to feel disappointed because reality did not match earlier, more exciting expectations
- Presence of mind — the ability to think quickly, and to act calmly and wisely, in a situation of danger and surprise
- Countenance — a person's face, or the expression it shows, here suggesting Max's sly, fox-like appearance
- Menacing — threatening; suggesting danger or harm, a quality the narrator says Max mostly lacks apart from his gun
Common errors and misconceptions
- Misconception: Max actually falls from a real balcony and is badly hurt or killed. Correct: the story never confirms this; it only shows Max dropping and screaming, while Ausable says "there is no balcony", leaving the consequence unstated.
- Misconception: Ausable is a traditional action-hero spy. Correct: he is deliberately described as fat, sloppy and unglamorous; his power lies in calm thinking, not physical action.
- Misconception: the knocking at the door is actually the police, as Ausable claims. Correct: it turns out to be only Henry the waiter with a drink that had been ordered earlier.
- Misconception: Max broke in through the invented balcony. Correct: Max says clearly that he entered using a passkey and did not even know about any balcony.
- Misconception: Fowler is the author of the story. Correct: Fowler is a character within the story; the author is Robert Arthur.
- Misconception: Ausable's balcony story is told for Max's benefit alone. Correct: Ausable also directs it partly at Fowler, glancing at him "explanatorily" while explaining the room's layout.
Exam-style questions with model answers
Q1. Why did Fowler feel disappointed when he first saw Ausable? [2 marks]
- Fowler had expected Ausable, a secret agent, to look like storybook spies, full of danger and romance.
- Instead he found a fat man with an American accent in a small, gloomy hotel room, which let him down.
Q2. How did Max enter Ausable's room? [2 marks]
- Max entered using a passkey, a key that could open the lock of Ausable's door.
- He explicitly says he did not know about any balcony, correcting Ausable's claim that he climbed in through it.
Q3. Describe how Ausable convinced Max that a balcony existed outside his window. [4 marks]
- As soon as he saw Max, Ausable loudly complained about "that nuisance of a balcony" outside his window.
- He explained that his room was once part of a larger unit, with the next room serving as the living room.
- He said that room's balcony now "extends under my window", reachable from an empty room two doors away.
- He added that the hotel management had promised to block this access but never had, making the detail sound like a long-standing, genuine problem rather than a sudden invention.
Q4. Explain how the knocking at the door helped Ausable resolve the dangerous situation. [4 marks]
- Ausable had already arranged for Henry, a waiter, to bring a drink to his room at a set time.
- When the knock came, Ausable told Max it was the police checking on him because of the important paper.
- Believing this, and already convinced a balcony existed, Max chose to escape through the window rather than be caught.
- Since there was no balcony, Max fell and screamed, removing the threat without any direct confrontation.
Q5. "Ausable did not fit any description of a secret agent." Discuss how the story uses this contrast between appearance and action to build its effect. [6 marks]
- The story opens by stressing that Ausable is "very fat," unglamorous, and speaks with a lingering American accent, directly contradicting Fowler's expectations of a dashing spy.
- Ausable himself names this disappointment, listing the dramatic things Fowler had imagined, "mysterious figures," "the crack of pistols," "drugs in the wine," before admitting his real evening was dull.
- This sets up the reader, like Fowler, to underestimate Ausable, which makes his later cleverness more striking by contrast.
- When Max appears with a pistol, real danger enters the ordinary room, and Ausable's calm, unhurried response, inventing a balcony and remembering an earlier arrangement with Henry, shows his true capability.
- His "presence of mind" lies entirely in thought and timing rather than any physical or dramatic action, which is unusual for a spy story.
- The final twist, that there was never a balcony at all, confirms that the story's real subject is intelligence and composure, not the appearance or theatrics readers, and Fowler, initially expected from a secret agent.
Q6. What happened to Max at the end of the story? [2 marks]
- Believing the balcony Ausable described was real, Max climbed out of the window to escape the supposed police.
- As he dropped, expecting to land on the balcony, he screamed shrilly, because, as Ausable reveals, there was no balcony there.
Key takeaways
- Ausable, a secret agent, is deliberately drawn as fat and unglamorous, contrasting with Fowler's expectations of a dramatic spy.
- Max threatens Ausable with a pistol, demanding an important report about new missiles.
- Ausable invents a detailed, convincing story about a balcony outside his window to trick Max.
- Max entered through a passkey, not a balcony, as he himself clarifies to Ausable.
- A prearranged knock from Henry the waiter, believed by Max to be the police, triggers Max's escape attempt.
- Max climbs out of the window believing the invented balcony is real, and falls, screaming.
- The story's final twist is Ausable's calm revelation that there is no balcony at all.
- The central theme is "presence of mind," the ability to think quickly and act calmly under danger.
Test yourself
What was Fowler's "first authentic thrill of the day"?
Seeing Max standing in the room with a small automatic pistol in his hand, once Ausable switched on the light.
What report did Max want from Ausable?
A report concerning some new missiles, which Max believed would be safer in his hands than in Ausable's.
How did Max actually enter Ausable's room?
Max used a passkey; he explicitly said he did not know about any balcony.
Who knocked at the door, and who did Ausable claim it was?
It was Henry, a waiter bringing a drink; Ausable had told Max it would be the police checking on him.
What did Max do when he thought the police had arrived?
He backed towards the window, swung his legs over the sill, and dropped onto what he believed was a balcony.
What is the final twist of the story?
Ausable reveals that there is no balcony at all, meaning his earlier description to Max was entirely invented.
What quality does the story say Ausable shows under danger?
"Presence of mind," the ability to think quickly and act calmly and wisely in a situation of surprise and danger.