Trial balance | ICSE Class 9 Commercial Studies Notes
On this page
What is a trial balance?
A trial balance is a statement showing the balances, or the total of debits and credits, of all the accounts in the ledger, prepared to verify the arithmetical accuracy of posting into the ledger accounts.
It is not an account and it is not part of the double-entry journal or ledger itself; it is a separate working statement drawn up from the ledger.
Because every transaction is recorded with an equal debit and an equal credit under the double-entry system, the sum of all debit balances in the ledger should equal the sum of all credit balances.
The trial balance is the tool that checks this. It usually carries a heading such as "Trial Balance of ... as on 31 March 2014" and has columns for the account title, ledger folio (L.F.), debit balance and credit balance.
A trial balance is an important statement in the accounting process because it shows the final position of all accounts together in one place and helps in preparing the final statements.
Preparing the final accounts becomes simpler because the accountant can take the balances of all accounts from the trial balance instead of going back through the entire ledger.
It is normally prepared with the balances of accounts, usually at the end of an accounting year, though an organisation may prepare one at the end of any chosen period, such as monthly, quarterly or half-yearly, depending on its requirements.
Definition: Trial balance. A statement showing the balances, or the totals of debits and credits, of all ledger accounts, prepared with a view to verify the arithmetical accuracy of ledger posting.
What are the advantages of preparing a trial balance?
A trial balance is prepared to fulfil three main objectives, and each one is a distinct advantage of drawing one up regularly.
First, it helps to ascertain arithmetical accuracy of the ledger accounts. When the totals of all the debit balances and all the credit balances in the trial balance are equal, it is assumed that the posting and balancing of accounts is arithmetically correct.
However, the tallying of the trial balance is not conclusive proof of the accuracy of the accounts; it only ensures that all debits and the corresponding credits have been properly recorded in the ledger.
Second, it helps in locating errors. When a trial balance does not tally, that is, when the totals of its debit and credit columns are not equal, it shows that at least one error has occurred, perhaps in totalling subsidiary books, posting journal entries, calculating account balances, carrying balances to the trial balance, or totalling the trial balance columns itself.
It should be kept in mind that equal totals do not guarantee there are no errors at all, since some errors (for example, an amount debited to the wrong account, or an equal wrong debit and credit of an incorrect amount) do not disturb the equality of debits and credits, so the trial balance can still tally.
Even so, agreement of the trial balance does suggest that several common types of error have probably not occurred.
Third, it helps in the preparation of financial statements. The trial balance is considered the connecting link between the accounting records and the preparation of financial statements.
All revenue and expense accounts appearing in the trial balance are carried to the trading and profit and loss account, and all liabilities, capital and asset accounts are carried to the balance sheet, so that the accountant need not refer back to the ledger at all.
Which accounts carry debit balances and which carry credit balances?
Before a trial balance can be prepared, every ledger account balance has to be placed in the correct column. All asset, expense and receivables accounts normally show debit balances, whereas all liability, revenue and payables accounts normally show credit balances.
| Account | Normal balance | Group |
|---|---|---|
| Land and Buildings | Debit | Asset |
| Plant and Machinery | Debit | Asset |
| Cash in Hand / Cash at Bank | Debit | Asset |
| Debtors / Bills Receivable | Debit | Asset (receivable) |
| Purchases, Carriage Inwards, Wages, Salaries | Debit | Expense |
| Sales Return, Drawings | Debit | Expense / withdrawal |
| Capital | Credit | Owner's equity |
| Long Term Loan, Bills Payable, Creditors | Credit | Liability (payable) |
| Sales, Interest received, Commission/Discount Received | Credit | Revenue |
| Interest Paid | Debit | Expense |
| Purchases Return, Advances from Customers | Credit | Liability / contra |
It may be noted that in a trial balance, instead of listing every individual account of debtors, a single combined figure of sundry debtors is usually shown; similarly a single figure of sundry creditors is shown instead of each individual creditor's account.
What are the steps in preparing a trial balance?
Preparing a trial balance follows a fixed sequence of steps, whichever method is used:
- Ascertain the balance of each account in the ledger.
- List each account title and place its balance in the debit or credit column, as the case may be. If an account has a zero balance, it may still be included with zero shown in the column for its normal balance.
- Compute the total of the debit balances column.
- Compute the total of the credit balances column.
- Verify that the sum of the debit balances equals the sum of the credit balances. If the two totals do not tally, it indicates that some error has occurred and the correctness of all account balances must be checked.
All assets, expenses and receivables accounts have debit balances, while all liabilities, revenues and payables accounts have credit balances, so this classification should be kept in mind while carrying out step 2 above.
What are the methods of preparing a trial balance?
Theoretically, a trial balance can be prepared in three ways.
Totals method
Under the totals method, the total of each side of a ledger account (the debit side total and the credit side total) is ascertained separately and shown in the trial balance in its own column.
The grand total of the debit column of the trial balance should agree with the grand total of the credit column, because the accounts are based on the double-entry system.
This method is not widely used in practice, because it does not help in assessing the correctness of the balances of various accounts or in preparing the financial statements.
Balances method
Under the balances method, the trial balance is prepared by showing only the closing balances of all ledger accounts, and then totalling the debit and credit columns of the trial balance to check that they agree.
This is the most widely used method in practice, because the balance of an account summarises the net effect of all the transactions relating to it and is what is actually needed when preparing the financial statements.
Totals-cum-balances method
The totals-cum-balances method combines the two methods above. Four amount columns are prepared: two for writing the debit and credit totals of each account, and two for writing the debit and credit balances of each account.
This method is also not used much in practice, because it is time-consuming and serves little additional purpose over the balances method.
Draw and label
format of a trial balance
Rule a table headed "Trial Balance of ... as on [date]" with four columns: Account Title, L.F. (ledger folio), Debit Balance (₹) and Credit Balance (₹).
List each ledger account on its own row with its balance in only one of the two amount columns, and total both amount columns at the bottom; the two totals must be equal.
How is a trial balance prepared from a given set of ledger balances?
When a question gives a ready list of ledger account balances rather than full ledger accounts, the task is simply to sort each balance into the correct column by its normal nature (debit or credit), list all the accounts, and total both columns so that they agree.
The worked examples below show this using the balances method, which is the method most commonly used.
Worked example 1. From the following ledger balances, prepare a trial balance by the balances method as on 31 March 2014: Rawat's Capital ₹60,000 (credit), Rohan's Account ₹20,000 (credit), Machinery ₹17,000 (debit), Rahul's Account ₹20,000 (debit), Sales ₹70,000 (credit), Cash ₹43,000 (debit), Wages ₹5,000 (debit), Depreciation ₹3,000 (debit), Purchases ₹62,000 (debit).
Answer: List the debit balances (Machinery ₹17,000 + Rahul ₹20,000 + Cash ₹43,000 + Wages ₹5,000 + Depreciation ₹3,000 + Purchases ₹62,000 = ₹1,50,000) against the credit balances (Rawat's Capital ₹60,000 + Rohan ₹20,000 + Sales ₹70,000 = ₹1,50,000). Both columns total ₹1,50,000, so the trial balance tallies.
Worked example 2. Using the same ledger accounts as Worked example 1, the totals method shows, instead, the total of each side of every account: Rawat's Capital ₹60,000 (credit total only); Rohan's Account ₹40,000 debit total and ₹60,000 credit total;
Machinery ₹20,000 debit total and ₹3,000 credit total; Rahul's Account ₹75,000 debit total and ₹55,000 credit total; Sales ₹70,000 credit total; Cash ₹1,00,000 debit total and ₹57,000 credit total; Wages ₹5,000 debit total; Depreciation ₹3,000 debit total; Purchases ₹62,000 debit total.
Answer: Adding every debit-side total (₹40,000 + ₹20,000 + ₹75,000 + ₹1,00,000 + ₹5,000 + ₹3,000 + ₹62,000) gives ₹3,05,000, and adding every credit-side total (₹60,000 + ₹60,000 + ₹3,000 + ₹55,000 + ₹70,000 + ₹57,000) also gives ₹3,05,000.
The totals method therefore uses larger figures than the balances method, because it adds up both sides of each account instead of just the net balance, but the grand totals still agree.
Worked example 3. Classify the following balances as debit or credit and state their account totals: Capital ₹1,00,000; Drawings ₹16,000; Machinery ₹20,000; Sales ₹2,00,000; Purchases ₹2,10,000; Sales return ₹20,000; Purchases return ₹30,000; Wages ₹40,000; Goodwill ₹60,000; Interest received ₹15,000;
Discount allowed ₹6,000; Bank overdraft ₹22,000; Bank loan ₹90,000; Debtors: Nathu ₹55,000, Roopa ₹20,000; Creditors: Reena ₹35,000, Ganesh ₹25,000; Cash ₹54,000; Stock on 1 April ₹16,000.
Answer: Debit balances are Drawings, Machinery, Purchases, Sales return, Wages, Goodwill, Discount allowed, the two Debtors, Cash and Stock. Credit balances are Capital, Sales, Purchases return, Interest received, Bank overdraft, Bank loan and the two Creditors. The completed trial balance totals ₹5,17,000 on each side.
What are the limitations of a trial balance?
A tallied trial balance is useful, but it is important to understand what it does and does not prove.
It is important for an accountant that the trial balance should tally, and normally a tallied trial balance means that both the debit and the credit entries have been made correctly for each transaction.
However, the agreement of a trial balance is not an absolute proof of accuracy of the accounting records.
A tallied trial balance only proves, to a certain extent, that the posting to the ledger is arithmetically correct; it does not guarantee that the entry itself was correct.
Some common errors make the two columns disagree: an error in totalling the trial balance or a subsidiary book, an error in posting a subsidiary book total, showing an account balance in the wrong column or with the wrong amount, omitting an account balance, an error in calculating a ledger balance, or posting an entry on the wrong side or with the wrong amount.
Other errors leave the trial balance in agreement: posting an amount to the wrong account on the correct side, recording a transaction with a reversed debit and credit, recording a wrong amount as both the debit and the credit, an error of principle, and two errors that compensate each other.
So a trial balance should be understood as a check of arithmetical accuracy of posting, not a complete guarantee that every transaction has been recorded and classified correctly.
Going beyond the syllabus
If a trial balance does not tally, the accountant has to carry forward the accounting process and still prepare financial statements.
One common practice is to put the difference between the two columns on the shorter side into a temporary account called the suspense account, so that the trial balance is made to agree while the actual error is searched for and, once found, corrected through a proper journal entry.
A useful check when hunting for the error is to see whether the difference between the two columns is divisible by 9, since this often points to a transposition of figures, that is, two digits written in the wrong order.
Worked example 4. A debit amount of ₹459 was wrongly posted as ₹954. Find the resulting difference in the trial balance and check whether it is divisible by 9.
Answer: The wrong posting of ₹954 instead of ₹459 makes the debit total exceed the credit total by ₹954 − ₹459 = ₹495. Dividing, ₹495 ÷ 9 = 55, which is a whole number, so the difference is exactly divisible by 9, consistent with a transposition error.
Errors that affect only one account (such as the one above) are generally the ones that disturb the agreement of the trial balance, while errors that affect two accounts equally and oppositely (such as recording a transaction completely in the wrong set of accounts, or two separate mistakes that happen to cancel out) often leave the trial balance tallying even though the books are not fully correct.
Glossary
- Trial balance: a statement showing the debit and credit balances, or totals, of all ledger accounts, prepared to check the arithmetical accuracy of posting.
- Ledger account balance: the net amount remaining in an account once its total debits and total credits have been compared.
- Debit balance: a balance on the debit side of an account, the normal balance for assets, expenses and receivables.
- Credit balance: a balance on the credit side of an account, the normal balance for liabilities, revenues, capital and payables.
- Balances method: preparing a trial balance by listing only the closing balance of each ledger account.
- Totals method: preparing a trial balance by listing the debit-side total and credit-side total of each ledger account.
- Totals-cum-balances method: a combined method showing both the totals and the balances of every account in four amount columns.
- Arithmetical accuracy: correctness of the addition, posting and balancing of ledger accounts, which the trial balance is used to check.
- Sundry debtors: a single combined figure shown in a trial balance instead of listing every individual debtor's balance.
- Sundry creditors: a single combined figure shown in a trial balance instead of listing every individual creditor's balance.
- Financial statements: the trading account, profit and loss account and balance sheet, prepared using the balances from the trial balance.
- Carriage inwards: expenditure on bringing purchased goods into the business, normally carrying a debit balance.
- Carriage outwards: expenditure on delivering goods to customers, normally carrying a debit balance.
- Suspense account: a temporary account in which the difference in a trial balance is placed until the error causing it is located and corrected.
- Transposition error: writing the digits of a figure in the wrong order, for example recording ₹459 as ₹954.
Common errors and misconceptions
- Misconception: a tallied trial balance proves there are no errors anywhere in the books. Correct: it only proves the arithmetical accuracy of posting; several kinds of error can occur while the two columns still agree.
- Misconception: a trial balance is itself a ledger account forming part of the double-entry system. Correct: it is a statement prepared from the ledger, not an account and not itself part of the double-entry books.
- Misconception: assets and expenses always appear in the credit column of a trial balance. Correct: assets, expenses and receivables normally carry debit balances; liabilities, revenues, capital and payables normally carry credit balances.
- Misconception: a trial balance can only be drawn up once, at the end of the accounting year. Correct: it may be prepared at any chosen period, such as monthly, quarterly or half-yearly, depending on the organisation's needs.
- Misconception: the totals method and the balances method give different final answers about the business. Correct: both methods must still show equal debit and credit column totals; they differ only in what figures are listed, not in the underlying correctness of the ledger.
- Misconception: every individual debtor's and creditor's account must be listed separately in the trial balance. Correct: normally only a single combined figure of sundry debtors and sundry creditors is shown.
Exam-style questions with model answers
Q1. State the meaning of a trial balance. [2 marks]
- It is a statement, not an account, showing the balances or totals of all ledger accounts.
- It is prepared to verify the arithmetical accuracy of posting into the ledger under the double-entry system.
Q2. State two objectives of preparing a trial balance. [2 marks]
- To ascertain the arithmetical accuracy of the ledger accounts.
- To help in the preparation of the financial statements, since balances can be taken directly from it.
Q3. List four steps you would follow to prepare a trial balance by the balances method. [4 marks]
- Ascertain the closing balance of each account in the ledger.
- List each account title and place its balance in the debit or credit column according to its normal nature.
- Compute the total of the debit balances column and the total of the credit balances column separately.
- Verify that the two column totals are equal, which shows that posting has been done arithmetically correctly.
Q4. Classify each of the following balances as debit or credit, stating the group to which each belongs: Machinery ₹20,000; Creditors ₹15,000; Sales ₹70,000; Purchases ₹62,000. [4 marks]
- Machinery ₹20,000 is a debit balance, as it is a fixed asset account.
- Creditors ₹15,000 is a credit balance, as it is a liability (payable) account.
- Sales ₹70,000 is a credit balance, as it is a revenue account.
- Purchases ₹62,000 is a debit balance, as it is an expense account.
Q5. Give three limitations of a trial balance. [3 marks]
- A tallied trial balance does not prove that every transaction was recorded; a complete omission affects no single column unevenly, so it still tallies.
- Posting a correct amount to the wrong account, or an error of principle such as treating a capital item as revenue, does not disturb the agreement of debit and credit totals.
- Two separate errors that happen to compensate each other's effect on the totals will leave the trial balance tallying even though the books contain mistakes.
Q6. From the following balances, prepare a trial balance as on 31 March by the balances method: Capital ₹60,000 (credit); Rohan's Account ₹20,000 (credit); Machinery ₹17,000 (debit); Rahul's Account ₹20,000 (debit); Sales ₹70,000 (credit); Cash ₹43,000 (debit); Wages ₹5,000 (debit); Depreciation ₹3,000 (debit); Purchases ₹62,000 (debit). [5 marks]
- Debit column: Machinery ₹17,000.
- Debit column: Rahul's Account ₹20,000, Cash ₹43,000.
- Debit column: Wages ₹5,000, Depreciation ₹3,000, Purchases ₹62,000, giving a debit total of ₹1,50,000.
- Credit column: Capital ₹60,000, Rohan's Account ₹20,000, Sales ₹70,000, giving a credit total of ₹1,50,000.
- Since both column totals equal ₹1,50,000, the trial balance tallies, confirming the arithmetical accuracy of the posting.
Q7. Why is the trial balance usually prepared with account balances rather than account totals? [2 marks]
The balance of an account summarises the net effect of all the transactions relating to it, which is exactly what is needed for preparing the financial statements. Using totals instead does not help in assessing the correctness of individual account balances.
Q8. Explain, with an example, why a tallied trial balance is not conclusive proof that the ledger accounts are completely free of errors. [6 marks]
- Tallying only shows that the sum of all debit balances equals the sum of all credit balances; it does not check whether each individual entry was recorded in the correct account.
- Some errors are "two-sided" in a way that leaves the totals undisturbed, for example debiting a correct amount to the wrong account while crediting the correct account, which gives two accounts incorrect balances but still lets the trial balance agree.
- Another such error is recording an equal but wrong amount as both the debit and the credit of a transaction, for instance recording a ₹10,000 purchase as ₹1,000 on both sides; the two account balances are wrong, but the equality of debits and credits is preserved.
- Errors of principle, such as treating capital expenditure as a revenue expense, change which account is debited but keep total debits equal to total credits, so the trial balance still tallies.
- Compensating errors, where two separate mistakes cancel out each other's effect on the totals, also leave the trial balance tallying.
- Therefore, an accountant must treat a tallied trial balance only as evidence of correct posting and totalling, not as a guarantee that every transaction has been classified correctly.
Key takeaways
- A trial balance is a statement, not an account, listing the debit and credit balances or totals of all ledger accounts.
- Its main objectives are to check arithmetical accuracy, help locate errors, and assist in preparing financial statements.
- Assets, expenses and receivables normally carry debit balances; liabilities, revenues, capital and payables normally carry credit balances.
- The balances method, which lists only closing balances, is the method most widely used in practice.
- The totals method lists both sides' totals for each account, and the totals-cum-balances method combines both approaches.
- Sundry debtors and sundry creditors are usually shown as single combined figures rather than individual accounts.
- A tallied trial balance proves arithmetical accuracy of posting, but it is not absolute proof that the accounting records are free from error.
- A difference in a trial balance that is divisible by 9 often points to a transposition of digits in a figure.
Test yourself
Is a trial balance part of the double-entry ledger?
No, it is a separate statement prepared from the ledger balances to check arithmetical accuracy; it is not itself an account.
Which column would a Drawings account balance normally appear in?
The debit column, since drawings reduce capital and behave like a withdrawal, which is a debit-type balance.
Name the most commonly used method of preparing a trial balance.
The balances method, which lists only the closing balance of each ledger account rather than both-sided totals.
Why is a single figure usually shown for "Sundry Debtors" instead of each debtor separately?
It simplifies the trial balance; the combined figure still represents the correct total amount owed by all debtors.
Does a tallied trial balance guarantee every transaction was recorded correctly?
No, errors such as wrong account posting, errors of principle and compensating errors can exist while the totals still agree.
If a debit figure of ₹459 is wrongly written as ₹954, what is the resulting difference, and is it divisible by 9?
The difference is ₹495 (₹954 minus ₹459), and ₹495 divided by 9 equals 55, so yes, it is exactly divisible by 9.
At what interval may an organisation choose to prepare a trial balance?
It may be prepared at the end of any chosen period, such as monthly, quarterly, half-yearly or annually, depending on its needs.
Write about it
Turn a question from this chapter into a paper.
The Writing Studio has a structure guide, a rubric and citation tools for 15 formats, from essays to research papers. A free account keeps up to five drafts. Learnacy Essential adds feedback from an AI writing coach and submission to The OYI Review.
Publication depends on review and is not guaranteed.
