The Taiwan Issue: Risk of War in the South China Sea?

The South China Sea is no stranger to geopolitical flashpoints. But in recent years, the Taiwan issue has emerged as the most volatile and potentially explosive of them all. As China intensifies its military pressure on Taiwan and the United States strengthens its support for the island, the risk of armed conflict is no longer hypothetical—it’s a rising concern for the global community.

What’s at stake is not just the future of Taiwan but the stability of the entire Indo-Pacific region and the global order that has prevailed since World War II. So, how did we get here, and how real is the risk of war?

Understanding the Taiwan Issue

1. A Disputed Legacy

At the heart of the Taiwan issue is the question of sovereignty.

• The People’s Republic of China (PRC) claims Taiwan as a breakaway province that must eventually be reunified with the mainland, by force if necessary.

• Taiwan, officially the Republic of China (ROC), considers itself a sovereign nation with its own democratic government, constitution, and military.

This dispute dates back to 1949, when the Chinese Civil War ended with the communist victory. The defeated Nationalist government retreated to Taiwan and continued to operate as the ROC. While the PRC controlled mainland China, Taiwan functioned independently.

2. Strategic Location

Taiwan’s location is vital in the broader geopolitical puzzle:

• Sits at the intersection of major shipping lanes.

• Acts as a buffer between China and U.S.-allied territories like Japan and the Philippines.

• Home to TSMC, the world’s most important semiconductor manufacturer.

Any conflict over Taiwan would likely drag in multiple nations and disrupt global trade, especially electronics and oil shipments.

China’s Position: “One China” and Reunification

1. The “One China” Principle

China's official stance is that there is only one China and that Taiwan is an inseparable part of it. The PRC has repeatedly stated its intention to achieve reunification—peacefully if possible, militarily if necessary.

President Xi Jinping has emphasized that reunification with Taiwan is a key part of the “great rejuvenation of the Chinese nation.”

2. Growing Military Pressure

Over the past few years, China has significantly increased military operations near Taiwan:

• Frequent incursions of Chinese fighter jets and bombers into Taiwan’s air defense identification zone (ADIZ).

• Naval exercises around the Taiwan Strait and South China Sea.

• Deployment of amphibious assault ships, hinting at preparation for a possible invasion.

These moves are intended to intimidate Taiwan and signal to the world that China is serious.

Taiwan’s Position: A De Facto Independent Nation

Taiwan, under both major political parties, has gradually moved toward greater assertion of its independence—even if it avoids formally declaring so, which could trigger a Chinese attack.

1. Vibrant Democracy

Taiwan is one of the most vibrant democracies in Asia. It has regular elections, an independent judiciary, and a thriving civil society. Its political identity is increasingly distinct from mainland China.

2. Public Sentiment

Surveys consistently show that the majority of Taiwanese people prefer the status quo—functional independence without provoking war. Very few support immediate reunification with China.

3. Defense Build-Up

In response to rising Chinese threats, Taiwan has increased defense spending, modernized its armed forces, and sought closer military ties with the U.S.

The United States: Strategic Ambiguity

1. Diplomatic Dance

The U.S. recognizes the One China policy, acknowledging that there is one China but not accepting China’s claim over Taiwan. This diplomatic ambiguity has kept the peace for decades.

However, under recent administrations—both Trump and Biden—the U.S. has:

• Increased arms sales to Taiwan.

• Sent congressional delegations and officials to Taipei.

• Publicly voiced support for Taiwan’s democratic system.

  
  

2. Military Posture

The U.S. Navy regularly conducts Freedom of Navigation Operations (FONOPs) in the Taiwan Strait and South China Sea to challenge Chinese claims and show support for allies in the region.

U.S. officials have made more explicit statements recently, warning that an invasion of Taiwan would have “serious consequences.”

The South China Sea Factor

Though Taiwan lies just north of the South China Sea, the two are deeply intertwined:

1. China’s Expanding Claims

China claims nearly the entire South China Sea under the so-called “Nine-Dash Line”, overlapping with claims from Vietnam, the Philippines, Malaysia, and Brunei. It has built artificial islands and militarized them.

2. Taiwan’s Strategic Position

Controlling Taiwan gives China a commanding position over the South China Sea, effectively turning it into a Chinese lake. It would also disrupt U.S. ability to project power in the Pacific.

3. Risk of Naval Clashes

U.S., Chinese, and allied warships often operate in close proximity in these contested waters. A miscalculation or accidental collision could spiral into a broader conflict.

What Would War Look Like?

A military conflict over Taiwan would not be easy for either side and would have global repercussions.

1. Invasion Scenario

China might attempt a full-scale amphibious invasion, but this would be logistically complex and risky, involving:

• A long cross-strait operation.

• Massive troop deployment.

• Heavy resistance from Taiwan and possibly U.S. or allied forces.
  

2. Blockade or Hybrid Warfare

Alternatively, China could opt for:

• A naval and air blockade to force Taiwan to negotiate.

• Cyberattacks, disinformation campaigns, and sabotage to destabilize Taiwan internally.
  

3. U.S. and Allied Response

If the U.S. intervenes militarily, Japan, Australia, and others may be drawn in. A regional war could follow, involving key U.S. bases in Okinawa, Guam, and beyond.

Global Implications of a Taiwan War

A war over Taiwan wouldn’t just be a regional crisis—it would be a global catastrophe.

1. Economic Shockwaves

• Disruption to the global semiconductor supply (90% of advanced chips come from Taiwan).

• Blocked trade through the South China Sea, impacting global oil, gas, and goods shipping.

• Massive stock market collapse and recession fears.
  

2. Humanitarian Disaster

• Thousands, if not millions, of civilian casualties.

• Refugee flows and humanitarian crises across the region.
  

3. Collapse of Global Order

Such a conflict would likely end the post-WWII rules-based order. It could:

• Accelerate militarization worldwide.

• Set off a new Cold War or hot wars in other contested regions (e.g., Korea, Ukraine).
  

Can War Be Avoided?

1. Diplomatic Engagement

Despite rhetoric, all sides are wary of open war. There remains room for diplomacy, including:

• Renewed talks between Beijing and Taipei.

• Confidence-building measures between China and the U.S.

• Multilateral engagement through ASEAN or the UN.
  

2. Deterrence Through Strength

The U.S. and allies aim to deter China from attacking by:

• Strengthening regional alliances (e.g., AUKUS, Quad).

• Bolstering Taiwan’s defense capabilities.

• Ensuring China knows the cost of war outweighs the benefits.
  

3. Economic Interdependence

China, Taiwan, and the U.S. are all economically linked. A war would devastate all economies involved. That’s a powerful disincentive—though not a guarantee of peace.

Conclusion: A Flashpoint That Must Be Handled Carefully

The Taiwan issue is more than a bilateral dispute. It's a test of whether the world can manage rising great-power competition without falling into war. The stakes could not be higher.

While a conflict is not inevitable, the path forward requires strategic patience, diplomatic creativity, and unwavering commitment to peace. Taiwan’s future will be shaped not only by military might but by the wisdom—or recklessness—of global leaders.

In a world already strained by climate change, economic uncertainty, and geopolitical realignments, a war in the Taiwan Strait would be catastrophic.

History offers many examples of misjudged red lines leading to devastating wars. Let’s hope this time, the world listens to history—not repeats it