Establishment of Indian democracy (1947 : 1966) | ISC Class 12 History Notes
On this page
This note covers the establishment of Indian democracy between 1947 and 1966: the integration of the princely states under Sardar Patel, the problems of Junagadh, Hyderabad and Kashmir, the first general election of 1952 with its problems of preparation, process, result and impact, and the linguistic reorganisation of states under the States Reorganisation Act, 1956, with particular reference to Andhra, Bombay and Punjab.
What was the background to the establishment of Indian democracy?
When India became independent at midnight on 14-15 August 1947, the new nation faced three linked challenges: shaping a united country out of great diversity, establishing democracy in practice (not merely on paper) and ensuring development with justice.
The Constitution granted fundamental rights, universal adult franchise and a parliamentary form of government, but a democratic constitution is necessary and not sufficient for establishing a democracy. The task was to make democratic practice work on the ground.
British India had been divided into British Indian Provinces, directly ruled by the Crown, and Princely States, which accepted British supremacy (called paramountcy or suzerainty) while retaining control over their internal affairs.
The princely states covered about one-third of the land area of British India, and roughly one in four Indians lived under princely rule.
Just before independence, the British announced that with the end of their rule, paramountcy over the princely states would also lapse: all 565 states would become legally free to join India, join Pakistan or remain independent, a decision left to the rulers rather than the people.
Definition: Paramountcy was the doctrine by which the British Crown held ultimate authority over the princely states while leaving their internal administration to the rulers. Its lapse in 1947 meant the rulers were, in theory, free to choose their state's future.
Why did integration of the princely states become urgent?
The rulers' freedom to choose created a real danger of India fragmenting into dozens of small, undemocratic principalities just as it had won independence.
The problems began almost immediately: the ruler of Travancore announced his state's independence, the Nizam of Hyderabad followed the next day, and rulers such as the Nawab of Bhopal were unwilling to join the Constituent Assembly.
Many princely states were tiny and scattered; the Saurashtra region of Gujarat alone had 14 big states, 119 small states and numerous other administrations, and Orissa had 26 small states.
Most princely governments were run in a non-democratic manner, so the prospects of democracy for their populations also looked bleak.
The interim government, under the Mountbatten Plan, held that the princely states were free to join either India or Pakistan.
Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel, Deputy Prime Minister and Home Minister of independent India, took on the task of negotiating with the rulers "firmly but diplomatically".
His approach rested on three considerations: most people in the princely states clearly wanted to join the Indian union; the government was willing to be flexible, offering autonomy to accommodate regional plurality; and after the trauma of partition, the integration of national territory had become supremely important.
In a letter to the princely rulers in 1947, Patel warned that "lack of unity will expose us to unexpected calamities" and that failure to cooperate would lead to "anarchy and chaos".
Before 15 August 1947 itself, almost all states contiguous to India's new boundaries had signed the Instrument of Accession, the document by which a ruler agreed that his state would become part of the Union of India.
What was Sardar Patel's role in the reorganisation and integration of the princely states?
Sardar Patel's task was not finished when a ruler signed the Instrument of Accession. Accession brought a state into the Union; it did not by itself turn hundreds of scattered principalities into workable units of administration.
Patel therefore worked for the consolidation of the princely states: small states were grouped together, or merged into neighbouring provinces, so that they could be governed as viable administrative units rather than surviving as tiny, separate principalities.
The scale of the problem was enormous. The Saurashtra region of Gujarat alone had 14 big states, 119 small states and numerous other administrations, and Orissa had 26 small states, all of which had to be brought together.
His method was skilful persuasion rather than force. He negotiated with the rulers firmly but diplomatically, and the government was prepared to be flexible, offering autonomy to some regions so that plurality could be accommodated within the Union. The rulers who acceded were allowed to keep privy purses and certain privileges, which were abolished in 1971.
Where a ruler held out, Patel was equally firm. The Nizam of Hyderabad sought independent status and signed only a Standstill Agreement in November 1947; when his Razakars terrorised the people, the central government ordered the army in, and in September 1948 the Nizam surrendered.
Patel's work thus had two sides: bringing the rulers into the Indian Union, and then reorganising and merging their states so that the map of India would not remain a patchwork of small principalities.
How did the integration of Junagadh, Hyderabad and Kashmir differ from one another?
Most states acceded peacefully before or soon after independence, but Junagadh, Hyderabad, Kashmir and Manipur proved far harder to resolve, each for different reasons.
Junagadh
Junagadh was a princely state in the Saurashtra region of Gujarat, surrounded by Indian territory and with a population that was overwhelmingly in favour of joining India.
Its ruler, however, chose to accede to Pakistan, and Pakistan accepted the accession. This was a serious problem for India, since the state lay far from Pakistan and its people did not wish to join that country.
The people of Junagadh opposed the ruler's decision, and a popular movement against the accession to Pakistan gathered force. India held that the ruler's choice could not override the clear wishes of the population.
Under this pressure the ruler fled, and the administration of the state passed into Indian hands. The issue of accession was then settled by a plebiscite, a direct vote of the people, which confirmed their desire to join India.
Junagadh therefore shows the principle that the wishes of the people, and not only the ruler's signature, decided the fate of a princely state.
Hyderabad
Hyderabad, the largest princely state, surrounded entirely by Indian territory, was ruled by the Nizam, one of the world's richest men, who wanted an independent status for his state.
He signed a Standstill Agreement with India in November 1947, buying a year for negotiations.
During this period a popular movement against Nizam's rule gathered force, especially among the peasantry of the Telangana region, with the Communists and the Hyderabad Congress in the forefront.
The Nizam responded by unleashing a paramilitary force called the Razakars, whose atrocities, including murder, maiming, rape and looting, targeted non-Muslims in particular.
The central government ordered the army in, and in September 1948 the Indian Army moved against the Nizam's forces; after a few days of fighting the Nizam surrendered, leading to Hyderabad's accession.
Kashmir
Kashmir's integration was complicated by its border with Pakistan and the religious composition of its population.
The state's Maharaja signed the Instrument of Accession with India, after which the dispute over the state's status became one of the most prolonged issues between India and Pakistan, eventually drawing in the United Nations.
Note: Do not confuse accession with merger. Accession (by the Instrument of Accession) only brought a state's defence, external affairs and communications under the Government of India; full merger into the administrative and political structure of India, with the ruler giving up all powers, came later through separate Merger Agreements, as happened in Manipur.
How did different groups participate in the integration of the princely states?
The Government of India and Sardar Patel
Patel led the negotiations, combining persuasion with firmness, and where persuasion failed, as in Hyderabad, the government was prepared to use military force to secure accession and prevent fragmentation of the new nation.
The rulers of the princely states
Rulers' responses varied widely: most quickly signed the Instrument of Accession, while some, such as the Nizam of Hyderabad and the ruler of Travancore, initially sought independence, and the ruler of Junagadh chose to accede to Pakistan.
The people of the princely states
The people were often the decisive force. The peasantry of Telangana, including large numbers of women who had suffered most under Nizam's oppressive rule, rose against him, supported by the Communists and the Hyderabad Congress, while in Junagadh the people's opposition to accession to Pakistan forced the issue to a plebiscite.
What problems did the first general election of 1952 face, and how were they solved?
The Constitution was adopted on 26 November 1949, signed on 24 January 1950 and came into effect on 26 January 1950. The Election Commission of India was set up in January 1950, with Sukumar Sen as the first Chief Election Commissioner, and elections were initially expected in 1950 itself.
- Holding the election required delimitation, drawing the boundaries of electoral constituencies, which was a lengthy task given India's size.
- Preparing the electoral rolls, the list of all citizens eligible to vote, was equally time-consuming; when the first draft was published, nearly 40 lakh women were found missing, recorded only as "wife of…" or "daughter of…". The Election Commission refused to accept these entries and ordered revision or deletion.
- With about 17 crore eligible voters needing to elect roughly 3,200 MLAs and 489 Members of the Lok Sabha, and only 15 per cent of voters literate, a special method of voting had to be devised.
- The Commission trained over 3 lakh officers and polling staff, and used a separate ballot box bearing each candidate's symbol in every polling booth, with about 20 lakh steel boxes prepared for the purpose, so illiterate voters could identify candidates by symbol.
Elections had to be postponed twice and were finally held from October 1951 to February 1952, taking six months to complete campaigning, polling and counting; because most of the country voted in January 1952, it is called the "1952 election".
Critics at home and abroad doubted the experiment: an Indian editor called it "the biggest gamble in history", and a British civil servant predicted "a future and more enlightened age will view with astonishment the absurd farce of recording the votes of millions of illiterate people."
What was the process, result and impact of the 1952 election?
On average there were more than four candidates for each seat, and more than half the eligible voters turned out to vote, a level of participation seen as encouraging for a largely illiterate electorate.
The Indian National Congress, inheriting the legacy of the freedom struggle and led by Jawaharlal Nehru, won 364 of the 489 seats in the first Lok Sabha; the Communist Party of India came next with only 16 seats.
The Congress also won a majority of seats in nearly every state assembly, except Travancore-Cochin, Madras and Orissa, where it still went on to form governments. Jawaharlal Nehru became Prime Minister.
The results were accepted as fair even by the losers. The Times of India wrote that the polls had "confounded all those sceptics who thought the introduction of adult franchise too risky an experiment in this country," while the Hindustan Times noted "universal agreement that the Indian people have conducted themselves admirably in the largest experiment in democratic elections in the history of the world." The 1952 election proved that democracy could be practised in conditions of poverty and widespread illiteracy, and it became a landmark in the world history of democracy, showing that free elections were no longer confined to prosperous, literate countries.
What were the features of the States Reorganisation Act, 1956?
During colonial rule, provincial boundaries had followed administrative convenience or the extent of British conquest, not language.
The national movement had rejected these divisions as artificial, and after the Nagpur session of the Congress in 1920, linguistic reorganisation of the party's own provincial committees had been accepted as a principle.
After independence, however, the leadership feared that carving states on linguistic lines might cause disruption soon after the trauma of partition, so the matter was postponed.
This postponement was challenged from below. In the Telugu-speaking areas of the old Madras province, the Vishalandhra movement demanded a separate Andhra state.
When the Centre vacillated, Congress leader and veteran Gandhian Potti Sriramulu began an indefinite fast on 19 October 1952 that led to his death on 15 December 1952 after 56 days, triggering unrest, violent outbursts and police firing. Sriramulu had already fasted once before, in 1946, demanding that temples in the Madras province be opened to dalits, showing his long record of fasting as a form of protest before his final fast for Andhra.
The Prime Minister announced the formation of a separate Andhra state in December 1952.
Andhra's formation spurred similar demands elsewhere, forcing the Centre to appoint the States Reorganisation Commission in 1953.
The Commission accepted that state boundaries should broadly reflect the boundaries of different languages, and on the basis of its report the States Reorganisation Act, 1956 was passed, creating 14 states and six union territories.
Andhra
Andhra was separated from the Madras province on linguistic lines, the first such state carved out as a result of the Vishalandhra movement and Potti Sriramulu's fast.
Bombay
Bombay remained for a time a "bilingual" state of Gujarati- and Marathi-speaking people. After a popular agitation, the states of Maharashtra and Gujarat were created in 1960, showing that the 1956 Act did not immediately or fully satisfy every linguistic demand.
Punjab
In Punjab there were two linguistic groups, Hindi-speaking and Punjabi-speaking, and the Punjabi-speaking population demanded a separate state; this was not granted with the other states in 1956.
Statehood for a Punjabi-speaking Punjab came only ten years later, in 1966, when the territories of present-day Haryana and Himachal Pradesh were separated from the larger Punjab state.
Note: A common error is to assume the 1956 Act settled all linguistic demands at once. It created 14 states and 6 union territories in 1956, but Bombay was split only in 1960 and Punjab only in 1966, showing reorganisation continued well beyond the Act itself.
What was the significance of these developments for Indian democracy?
The successful integration of the princely states, achieved mainly through negotiation and the Instrument of Accession, with force used only in Hyderabad, ensured that India did not fragment into small, often undemocratic principalities at the very moment of independence, and brought democratic government to areas that had never known it.
The 1952 general election demonstrated, against widespread scepticism, that free and fair elections with universal adult franchise could be conducted successfully in a vast, poor and largely illiterate country, and it established the legitimacy of electoral competition as the basis of Indian democratic politics for decades afterwards.
The linguistic reorganisation of states, far from causing the disintegration that many leaders had feared, is generally seen to have strengthened national unity, because it accommodated regional and linguistic aspirations within the democratic framework rather than leaving them to fester outside it.
It also widened access to politics and power beyond a small, English-speaking elite, and the reorganisation of boundaries along linguistic lines continued for decades after 1956, as seen in the creation of Nagaland (1963), Meghalaya, Manipur and Tripura (1972), Mizoram and Arunachal Pradesh (1987), Chhattisgarh, Uttarakhand and Jharkhand (2000), and Telangana (2014).
Timeline of the establishment of Indian democracy, 1947-1966
| Year | Event |
|---|---|
| 1947 | Lapse of British paramountcy over princely states; most states sign the Instrument of Accession before or soon after 15 August; Nizam of Hyderabad signs a Standstill Agreement in November |
| 1948 | Indian Army acts against Hyderabad and the Nizam surrenders (September); Mahatma Gandhi assassinated (30 January) |
| 1949 | Constitution of India adopted (26 November) |
| 1950 | Constitution comes into effect (26 January); Election Commission of India set up |
| 1951-52 | First general election held across the country (October 1951 to February 1952); Congress wins 364 of 489 Lok Sabha seats |
| 1952 | Potti Sriramulu's fast (from 19 October) and death (15 December); formation of a separate Andhra state announced |
| 1953 | States Reorganisation Commission appointed |
| 1956 | States Reorganisation Act passed; creation of 14 states and 6 union territories |
| 1960 | Bombay state divided into Maharashtra and Gujarat |
| 1966 | Punjab reorganised into Punjab, Haryana and Himachal Pradesh |
Going beyond the syllabus
These ideas extend the unit and are not needed for the questions on it.
How did the Kashmir dispute develop after accession?
In October 1947, tribal raiders backed from Pakistan invaded the state, and the Maharaja, Hari Singh, signed the Instrument of Accession to India on 26 October 1947 before Indian troops were airlifted to defend Srinagar. Fighting between Indian and Pakistani forces continued into 1948, and India referred the dispute to the United Nations Security Council in January 1948. A ceasefire came into effect in January 1949, establishing a ceasefire line, later called the Line of Control, that still divides the state between India and Pakistan. Unlike Junagadh, settled by a plebiscite, or Hyderabad, settled by military action entirely within India's own territory, Kashmir's accession became entangled with an unresolved international dispute.
How did Manipur join the Indian Union?
A few days before independence, the Maharaja of Manipur, Bodhachandra Singh, signed the Instrument of Accession on the assurance that the internal autonomy of Manipur would be maintained. Under pressure of public opinion, elections were held in Manipur in June 1948 and the state became a constitutional monarchy, the first part of India to hold an election based on universal adult franchise. In its Legislative Assembly the state Congress favoured merger while other parties opposed it, and the Government of India persuaded the Maharaja to sign a Merger Agreement in September 1949.
What happened in the later general elections?
In the second and third general elections, held in 1957 and 1962, the Congress maintained its position in the Lok Sabha by winning three-fourths of the seats. The most significant exception in the state elections came in Kerala in 1957, when a coalition led by the Communist Party of India formed the government.
Which states were created later?
State creation continued after the reorganisation of 1956: Nagaland (1963), Meghalaya, Manipur and Tripura (1972), Mizoram and Arunachal Pradesh (1987), Chhattisgarh, Uttarakhand and Jharkhand (2000), and Telangana (2014).
Glossary
- Paramountcy: the British Crown's ultimate authority over the princely states, which lapsed with the end of British rule in 1947.
- Princely State: a state ruled by a hereditary prince who accepted British supremacy while retaining internal self-government.
- Instrument of Accession: the document by which a princely ruler agreed that his state would join the Union of India.
- Standstill Agreement: a temporary agreement, as with Hyderabad, continuing existing arrangements while fuller negotiations took place.
- Razakars: the Nizam of Hyderabad's paramilitary force used to suppress the popular movement against his rule.
- Plebiscite: a direct vote by which the people of an area express their wish on a political question, used to decide Junagadh's accession.
- Merger Agreement: the document by which a ruler gave up all remaining governing powers to the Indian state.
- Delimitation: the drawing of boundaries of electoral constituencies before an election.
- Electoral rolls: the official list of citizens eligible to vote in an election.
- Universal adult franchise: the right of every adult citizen to vote, regardless of property, education or gender.
- Vishalandhra movement: the movement demanding that Telugu-speaking areas be separated from Madras province to form Andhra.
- States Reorganisation Commission: the body appointed in 1953 to examine redrawing state boundaries on linguistic lines.
- Linguistic reorganisation: the restructuring of state boundaries to match the areas where particular languages were spoken.
Common errors and misconceptions
- Misconception: Accession automatically meant full merger of a princely state into India. Correct: Accession under the Instrument of Accession only transferred defence, external affairs and communications; full merger came through separate agreements.
- Misconception: All princely states joined India peacefully by August 1947. Correct: Most did, but Junagadh required a plebiscite, Hyderabad military action, and Kashmir remained a prolonged dispute.
- Misconception: The first general election was held entirely in 1951. Correct: Polling ran from October 1951 to February 1952, but it is called the 1952 election because most of the country voted in January 1952.
- Misconception: The States Reorganisation Act, 1956, settled all demands for linguistic states at once. Correct: Bombay was divided into Maharashtra and Gujarat only in 1960, and Punjab was reorganised only in 1966.
- Misconception: Sardar Patel used force to integrate all the princely states. Correct: Most states acceded through negotiation; military action was used chiefly in Hyderabad, after the Nizam's refusal to accede and the Razakars' violence.
- Misconception: Linguistic reorganisation weakened national unity. Correct: It is generally held to have strengthened unity by accommodating regional aspirations within the democratic framework rather than leaving them unaddressed.
Exam-style questions with model answers
Q1. Define the term plebiscite. [2 marks]
- A plebiscite is a direct vote in which the people of an area express their wish on a political question.
- In the case of Junagadh, the plebiscite confirmed the people's desire to join India.
Q2. State any two problems faced in preparing for the first general election of 1952. [2 marks]
- Delimitation, the drawing of constituency boundaries across a vast country, took a long time to complete.
- When the first draft of the electoral rolls was published, nearly 40 lakh women were not recorded by name, listed only as "wife of…" or "daughter of…", so the Election Commission had to order revision or deletion of these entries.
Q3. State any four circumstances that led to the fulfilment of the wishes of the people of Junagadh and its eventual accession to the Indian Union. [4 marks]
- Junagadh was surrounded by Indian territory, and its population was overwhelmingly in favour of joining India.
- Its ruler nevertheless chose to accede to Pakistan, and Pakistan accepted the accession, which India refused to accept.
- The people of Junagadh opposed the ruler's decision, and a popular movement against accession to Pakistan gathered force.
- Under this pressure the ruler fled and the administration passed into Indian hands, after which a plebiscite confirmed the people's desire to join India.
Q4. Explain Sardar Patel's role in the reorganisation and integration of the princely states. [4 marks]
- As Deputy Prime Minister and Home Minister, Patel negotiated with the rulers firmly but diplomatically and brought most of them into the Indian Union through the Instrument of Accession.
- He worked for the consolidation of small and scattered states into viable administrative units, as in Saurashtra, which had 14 big states and 119 small states, and Orissa, which had 26 small states.
- His approach was flexible, offering autonomy to some regions so that plurality could be accommodated within the Union.
- Where a ruler resisted, as the Nizam of Hyderabad did, the government acted firmly, and the Indian Army moved in during September 1948 until the Nizam surrendered.
Q5. Distinguish between the problems of integrating Junagadh and Hyderabad into the Indian Union. [4 marks]
- Junagadh's ruler chose to accede to Pakistan even though the state was surrounded by Indian territory and its people wished to join India.
- The Junagadh issue was settled by a plebiscite, which confirmed the people's desire to join India.
- Hyderabad's Nizam wanted independent status and signed only a Standstill Agreement with India in November 1947.
- Hyderabad was integrated by military action, when the Indian Army moved in during September 1948 and the Nizam surrendered after a few days of fighting.
Q6. Discuss any eight features of the States Reorganisation Act, 1956, with particular reference to Andhra, Bombay and Punjab. [8 marks]
- The Act followed the report of the States Reorganisation Commission, appointed in 1953 after sustained agitation for linguistic states.
- The Commission accepted that state boundaries should broadly reflect the boundaries of different languages.
- On the basis of its report the States Reorganisation Act was passed in 1956.
- The Act led to the creation of 14 states and six union territories.
- Andhra had already been separated from Madras province in December 1952, after the Vishalandhra movement and Potti Sriramulu's fast unto death.
- Bombay remained a bilingual state of Gujarati- and Marathi-speaking people even under the 1956 Act.
- Bombay was divided into Maharashtra and Gujarat only after further agitation, in 1960.
- Punjab's Punjabi-speaking population did not get a separate state in 1956, and statehood came only in 1966, when Haryana and Himachal Pradesh were separated from it.
Q7. Evaluate the impact of the first general election of 1952 on Indian democracy. [8 marks]
- The election was a mammoth exercise: about 17 crore eligible voters had to elect roughly 3,200 MLAs and 489 Members of the Lok Sabha.
- Only 15 per cent of the voters were literate, so the Election Commission used a separate ballot box with each candidate's symbol, preparing about 20 lakh steel boxes.
- The Commission trained over 3 lakh officers and polling staff to conduct the election.
- Critics doubted the experiment; an Indian editor called it "the biggest gamble in history", and a British civil servant mocked the idea of recording the votes of millions of illiterate people.
- Polling was held from October 1951 to February 1952, with more than four candidates per seat on average and more than half the eligible voters turning out.
- The Indian National Congress won 364 of the 489 Lok Sabha seats, and the results were accepted as fair even by the losers.
- The election proved that democracy could be practised in conditions of poverty and widespread illiteracy.
- It became a landmark in the world history of democracy, showing that free elections were no longer confined to prosperous, literate countries.
Key takeaways
- Paramountcy lapsed in 1947, leaving 565 princely states free to choose India, Pakistan or independence.
- Sardar Patel negotiated most accessions through persuasion and worked to consolidate small states into viable units, using force only in Hyderabad.
- Junagadh's accession was settled by a plebiscite, Hyderabad's by military action, and Kashmir's became a prolonged international dispute.
- The first general election (1951-52) overcame huge problems of scale, illiteracy and electoral rolls through delimitation, symbol-based ballot boxes and mass training of staff.
- The Congress won 364 of 489 Lok Sabha seats in 1952, and the election's success proved democracy could work amid poverty and illiteracy.
- Linguistic reorganisation began with Andhra in December 1952, following Potti Sriramulu's fast, and culminated in the States Reorganisation Act, 1956.
- The 1956 Act created 14 states and 6 union territories, but Bombay was split only in 1960 and Punjab reorganised only in 1966.
- Linguistic reorganisation strengthened rather than weakened national unity, accommodating regional aspirations within a democratic framework.
Test yourself
What was paramountcy, and what happened to it in 1947?
Paramountcy was the British Crown's ultimate authority over the princely states; it lapsed with the end of British rule, leaving states free to choose their future.
How did the Hyderabad problem finally get resolved?
After the Nizam refused accession and his Razakars used violence against the popular movement, the Indian Army acted in September 1948 and the Nizam surrendered.
How was the Junagadh issue settled?
Its ruler acceded to Pakistan, but the people opposed this, the ruler fled, and a plebiscite confirmed the people's desire to join India.
Why was preparing the electoral rolls for 1952 so difficult?
Many women were listed only as "wife of…" or "daughter of…" rather than by name, and the Election Commission had to order corrections across a vast, mostly illiterate electorate.
Who was Potti Sriramulu, and why is he remembered?
He was a Gandhian Congress leader whose fast unto death, from October to December 1952, forced the government to create a separate Andhra state.
What happened to Bombay state after the 1956 Act?
It remained bilingual for a few more years until popular agitation led to its division into Maharashtra and Gujarat in 1960.
When and how did Punjab get reorganised on linguistic lines?
In 1966, ten years after the main Act, when Haryana and Himachal Pradesh were separated from Punjab.
Write about it
Turn a question from this chapter into a paper.
The Writing Studio has a structure guide, a rubric and citation tools for 15 formats, from essays to research papers. A free account keeps up to five drafts. Learnacy Essential adds feedback from an AI writing coach and submission to The OYI Review.
Publication depends on review and is not guaranteed.
