Development of Indian Democracy (1964 : 1977) | ISC Class 12 History Notes
On this page
This note covers the political history of India from 1964 to 1977: Lal Bahadur Shastri's contribution as Prime Minister; the importance of the 1967 general election; the ideologies of the main Opposition parties (Socialist Party, CPI, CPI(M), Bharatiya Jan Sangh and Shiromani Akali Dal); the rise, course and decline of the Naxal Movement; the origin and significance of the JP Movement (1974-75); and the reasons, features and impact of the Emergency (1975-76).
Background to the crisis of democratic order (1964-1967)
Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru died in May 1964 after being unwell for more than a year.
His death raised a serious question for a newly independent country: would India's democratic experiment survive after him? Many observers abroad doubted that a new leadership could manage a peaceful succession and feared a political role for the army.
These fears proved wrong. Congress President K. Kamaraj, who had earlier proposed in 1963 that senior Congressmen should resign from office to make way for younger party workers (known as the Kamaraj Plan), consulted party leaders and Congress MPs and found a consensus in favour of Lal Bahadur Shastri (born 1904), who was unanimously chosen as leader of the Congress parliamentary party and became Prime Minister.
Shastri was a non-controversial leader from Uttar Pradesh who had been a minister in Nehru's cabinet for many years; he had earlier resigned as Railway Minister, accepting moral responsibility for a major railway accident, which reflected his commitment to principle.
As Prime Minister (1964 to 1966), Shastri faced two major challenges: the country was still recovering economically from the war with China, and failed monsoons brought drought and a serious food crisis.
India also fought a war with Pakistan in 1965. His famous slogan "Jai Jawan Jai Kisan" symbolised the country's resolve to face both challenges together, honouring the soldier and the farmer.
Shastri's Prime Ministership ended abruptly when he died suddenly in Tashkent (then in the USSR) on 11 January 1966, where he had gone to sign an agreement with Pakistani President Muhammad Ayub Khan to end the war.
The Congress then faced succession for a second time in two years, with an intense contest between Morarji Desai and Indira Gandhi (born 1917), resolved through a secret ballot among Congress MPs.
Indira Gandhi defeated Morarji Desai by securing the support of more than two-thirds of the party's MPs, a peaceful transition seen as a sign of the maturity of India's democracy.
Why was the 1967 election a turning point?
The years leading up to the fourth general election of 1967 were marked by grave economic crisis: successive failures of the monsoon, widespread drought, falling agricultural and industrial output, depleted foreign exchange reserves and a sharp rise in military expenditure.
One of Indira Gandhi's early decisions was the devaluation of the rupee, seen as taken under pressure from the United States; the dollar's cost rose from under Rs 5 to over Rs 7.
This triggered price rises, and bandhs and hartals were called frequently as people protested over scarcity and unemployment.
In this climate, opposition parties organised popular protests, and the socialist leader Ram Manohar Lohia advanced the strategy of 'non-Congressism': the argument that Congress rule was undemocratic and against the interests of ordinary poor people, so non-Congress parties, however different their ideologies, should come together to defeat Congress rather than split the anti-Congress vote.
The election results, held in February 1967, were described by observers as a "political earthquake".
Congress retained its Lok Sabha majority but with its lowest tally of seats and share of votes since 1952; half of Indira Gandhi's cabinet ministers lost their seats, and political stalwarts such as Kamaraj in Tamil Nadu and S.K. Patil in Maharashtra also lost in their constituencies.
Far more dramatic was the result at the State level: Congress lost its majority in seven States, and defections prevented it from forming a government in two more, so it lost power altogether in nine States, including Punjab, Haryana, Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, West Bengal and Madras.
In Madras State, the Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (DMK), a regional party, won a clear majority of its own, the first time any non-Congress party had done so in any State.
Because no single party had won a majority in most of these States, rival non-Congress parties came together to form Samyukt Vidhayak Dal (SVD) coalition governments, often among ideologically incongruent partners.
This period also gave rise to the phrase "Aya Ram, Gaya Ram", describing frequent floor-crossing by legislators, after a Haryana MLA, Gaya Lal, changed his party three times in a fortnight in 1967.
The 1967 verdict thus ended the uncontested dominance the Congress had enjoyed since 1952 and made coalition politics, defections and a more polarised party competition a recurring feature of Indian democracy.
What did the main Opposition parties stand for?
The Opposition that challenged Congress after 1967 was not a single bloc but a set of parties with sharply different ideologies, which is why most anti-Congress coalitions proved difficult to hold together.
Socialist Party (SP)
Associated with leaders such as Ram Manohar Lohia, the Socialist Party advocated a non-European socialist theory of social and economic equality, attacked Congress's claim to represent the nation, pressed for reservation for backward castes and opposed the dominance of the English language.
Lohia's strategy of 'non-Congressism' was the Socialist Party's main contribution to the politics of this period, aiming to unite non-Congress forces to defeat the ruling party.
Communist Party of India (CPI) and CPI(M)
The Communist Party of India (CPI) worked largely within the parliamentary system; after the 1969 Congress split it extended issue-based support to Indira Gandhi's government and later allied formally with her Congress(R) in the 1971 election.
The Communist Party of India (Marxist), or CPI(M), had emerged from an earlier split in the undivided communist movement and took a more radical left position; some groups within and around it broke away in the late 1960s because they did not believe in parliamentary politics at all, choosing instead to take up arms, and these became the Naxalite or Marxist-Leninist groups described below.
The CPI accepted parliamentary democracy and electoral competition as the road to socialism, and was willing to support a Congress government on particular issues; the CPI(M) held that the Indian state was dominated by big business and landlords, that parliamentary politics alone could not end their power, and that mass struggles of workers and peasants were needed alongside elections.
Bharatiya Jan Sangh
The Bharatiya Jan Sangh was part of several SVD coalitions after 1967, for example in Bihar's SVD government alongside socialist and communist parties, and was a leading member of the Grand Alliance against Indira Gandhi in the 1971 election.
It later became one of the founding constituents of the Janata Party formed on the eve of the 1977 election.
Ideologically, the Jan Sangh stood for cultural nationalism and drew its support mainly from the Hindi-speaking north, the urban middle classes and traders; it opposed the special status given to Kashmir and pressed for a uniform civil code and a ban on cow slaughter.
Shiromani Akali Dal
The Shiromani Akali Dal, representing regional Sikh and Punjab interests, took part in Punjab's 'Popular United Front' SVD government of 1967, a coalition that brought together its two rival factions (the Sant group and the Master group) with both communist parties, the Socialist Party and the Jan Sangh, illustrating how disparate the anti-Congress coalitions of this period could be.
Its ideology combined Sikh religious and cultural identity with regional autonomy: it argued that Punjab had been treated unfairly in the division of river waters and in the share of resources and industry, and demanded greater powers for the States within the Indian Union.
What were the causes behind the rise of the Naxal Movement?
By the late 1960s there was an increase in the activities of Marxist groups who did not believe in parliamentary politics.
These groups had taken to arms and insurgent techniques for the overthrow of the capitalist order and the established political system.
Known as Marxist-Leninist (now Maoist) groups or Naxalites, they were particularly strong in West Bengal, where the State government took stringent measures to suppress them.
Their rise was linked to a wider atmosphere of economic distress: agrarian inequality, falling agricultural output after poor monsoons, high inflation (prices rose 23 per cent in 1973 and 30 per cent in 1974) and the persistence of students' unrest that had continued since the late 1960s, all of which created conditions in which radical, non-parliamentary politics found support among landless peasants and students.
The movement is traditionally associated with the uprising that began in 1967 at Naxalbari in West Bengal, from which it took its name, and with the leadership of Charu Majumdar and Kanu Sanyal, who organised peasants against landlords and moneylenders over issues of land and debt.
Student groups in Calcutta and other parts of West Bengal were drawn into the movement, giving it both a peasant and a student base.
The movement is also associated with areas in West Bengal and Andhra Pradesh, where similar agrarian unrest among sharecroppers and landless labourers provided fertile ground for the Naxalite appeal.
How did the government respond, and why did the Naxal Movement decline in the 1970s?
State and central governments treated the Naxalite insurgency as a serious law-and-order challenge. In West Bengal, the State government took stringent measures to suppress the movement, including police action against its cadres and its peasant and student bases.
Charu Majumdar had formed the Communist Party of India (Marxist-Leninist) in 1969 to give the movement an organisational form committed to armed struggle rather than elections.
The movement declined through the 1970s for several reasons: sustained and often harsh police action weakened its organisational networks in its West Bengal and Andhra Pradesh strongholds; the loss of senior leadership, including Charu Majumdar, who died in 1972; and internal splits among different Naxalite factions over strategy and ideology, which fragmented the movement rather than consolidating it.
Its impact, however, was lasting: it kept alive a tradition of agrarian radicalism and armed insurgency on India's political margins, it forced governments to pay closer attention to rural landlessness and agrarian distress, and the questions it raised about peasant exploitation remained unresolved issues in Indian politics well beyond the 1970s.
What were the origins of the JP Movement (1974-75)?
The JP Movement grew out of student protests against rising prices, scarcity and corruption. In January 1974, students in Gujarat, a Congress-ruled State, started an agitation over rising prices of food grains and cooking oil and against corruption in high places; it became widespread enough to lead to the imposition of President's rule, and Morarji Desai announced an indefinite fast demanding fresh elections, which were eventually held in June 1975, resulting in Congress's defeat in the State.
In March 1974, students in Bihar began a similar protest against rising prices, food scarcity, unemployment and corruption. They invited Jayaprakash Narayan (JP), who had given up active politics for social work, to lead the movement.
JP accepted on condition that the movement remain non-violent and not confine itself to Bihar. This gave the students' protest a political character and national appeal.
JP demanded the dismissal of the Bihar government and called for 'Total Revolution' in the social, economic and political spheres, aiming to establish what he considered true democracy; a popular slogan of the movement was "Sampoorna Kranti ab nara hai, bhavi itihas hamara hai" (With Total Revolution as our motto, the future belongs to us).
The underlying dispute between JP and Indira Gandhi arose because the Gujarat and Bihar agitations, though directed against State governments, were widely seen as protests against the personalisation of political authority under Mrs Gandhi's leadership, a reading she herself shared, believing the movement was motivated by personal opposition to her.
What were the main features of the JP Movement's course, and how significant was it?
The movement spread through bandhs, gheraos and strikes against the Bihar government, which refused to resign.
In May 1974, the National Coordination Committee for Railwaymen's Struggle, led by George Fernandes, called a nationwide strike by Railway employees over bonus and service conditions; the government declared it illegal, arrested leaders, deployed the territorial army to protect railway tracks and the strike was called off after twenty days without settlement, but it added greatly to the atmosphere of labour unrest and raised questions about the right of essential-service employees to strike.
In 1975, JP led a people's march to Parliament, one of the largest political rallies ever held in the capital, with support from non-Congress opposition parties such as the Bharatiya Jana Sangh, Congress(O), the Bharatiya Lok Dal and the Socialist Party, all of whom projected JP as an alternative to Indira Gandhi.
On 25 June 1975, after the Allahabad High Court had set aside Indira Gandhi's election, JP organised a massive demonstration at Delhi's Ramlila grounds, announced a nationwide satyagraha demanding her resignation, and asked the army, the police and government employees not to obey "illegal and immoral orders."
The movement's significance lies in its transformation of scattered price-rise and anti-corruption protests into a sustained, nationally organised challenge to the ruling party, led by a figure of great moral authority.
It brought together ideologically diverse opposition parties around a common platform, made JP a national symbol of resistance to the Emergency that followed, and became the moving force behind the eventual formation of the Janata Party.
At the same time, it also drew criticism, including from the government, for the politics of mass agitation it employed and for its call to government employees and the army to disobey orders, which some saw as a threat to ordered constitutional government.
Why was the Emergency of 1975-76 imposed?
Several strands came together to provoke the imposition of Emergency. Politically, party competition had become bitter and polarised since 1967, and relations between the government and the judiciary had grown tense: the Supreme Court had found several government initiatives, including attempts to curtail Fundamental Rights and the right to property through constitutional amendment, to be unconstitutional, a conflict that culminated in the Kesavananda Bharati case of 1973, in which the Court held that Parliament could not amend certain 'basic features' of the Constitution.
Soon after this judgment, the government set aside the seniority of three judges to appoint Justice A.N. Ray as Chief Justice in 1973, a move seen as politically controversial because the superseded judges had ruled against the government.
Economically, the social and economic condition of the country had not improved much after the 1971 slogan of garibi hatao.
The Bangladesh crisis and the 1971 war with Pakistan strained the economy; the US stopped aid; international oil prices rose sharply; prices rose 23 per cent in 1973 and 30 per cent in 1974; industrial growth was low and unemployment high, especially in rural areas; the government froze employees' salaries, causing further dissatisfaction; and the failure of the monsoon in 1972-73 caused food grain output to fall by 8 per cent.
This widespread economic hardship allowed opposition parties to organise effective popular protests, including the Gujarat and Bihar movements described above.
The immediate trigger came on 12 June 1975, when Justice Jagmohanlal Sinha of the Allahabad High Court, ruling on an election petition filed by the socialist leader Raj Narain, declared Indira Gandhi's 1971 election to the Lok Sabha invalid on the ground that she had used government servants in her campaign.
This meant she could not remain Prime Minister unless re-elected as an MP within six months.
On 24 June 1975, the Supreme Court granted her only a partial stay: she could remain an MP pending appeal but could not take part in Lok Sabha proceedings.
With JP's satyagraha call of 25 June threatening to bring government activity to a standstill, the government responded that night by declaring a state of emergency on the ground of a perceived threat of internal disturbance, invoking Article 352 of the Constitution, which permits emergency on grounds of external threat or internal disturbance.
Note: a common confusion. Students often assume that any 'Emergency' must be caused by war or a natural disaster, since those are the familiar associations of the word. The Emergency of 1975 was neither: it was imposed on the ground of a perceived threat of internal disturbance, a category Article 352 also permits, arising from the political and judicial confrontation described above rather than from any external attack or calamity.
What were the main features of the suspension of democratic rights during the Emergency?
On the night of 25 June 1975, Prime Minister Indira Gandhi recommended Emergency to President Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed, who issued the proclamation at once; electricity to major newspaper offices was cut after midnight, and large numbers of opposition leaders and workers were arrested in the early morning, before the Cabinet itself was informed at a special meeting at 6 a.m. on 26 June.
- Once Emergency is proclaimed, the federal distribution of powers remains practically suspended and all powers concentrate in the union government.
- The government gains the power to curtail or restrict all or any of the Fundamental Rights; most importantly, the Fundamental Rights of citizens stood suspended, including the right to move the Court to restore them.
- Agitation was brought to an abrupt stop, strikes were banned, and many opposition leaders were jailed.
- Press censorship was imposed: newspapers had to get prior approval before publishing material; some, like the Indian Express and the Statesman, protested by leaving blank spaces where news had been censored, a practice that was itself later banned.
- Organisations such as the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) and Jamait-e-Islami were banned, and public protests, strikes and agitations were disallowed.
- The government made extensive use of preventive detention, arresting and detaining people not because they had committed an offence but on the apprehension that they might; arrested persons could not successfully challenge their arrest through habeas corpus petitions, since in April 1976 the Supreme Court's constitution bench over-ruled High Courts that had allowed such petitions, and accepted the government's plea that even the right to life and liberty could be taken away during Emergency, a judgment widely regarded as one of the Court's most controversial.
Parliament also amended the Constitution during this period: an amendment declared that the election of the Prime Minister, President and Vice-President could not be challenged in court, and the forty-second amendment made a series of changes, including extending the duration of legislatures from five to six years, a change intended to be permanent and not confined to the Emergency, and allowing elections to be postponed by a year, so that, after 1971, elections needed to be held only in 1978 instead of 1976.
Some acts of dissent continued despite censorship, notably the Kannada writer Shivarama Karanth and the Hindi writer Fanishwarnath Renu, who returned their government awards in protest; but by and large, such open acts of defiance and resistance were rare.
Assessment of the Emergency's impact: what were its positive and negative aspects?
On the negative side, the Emergency suspended Fundamental Rights, including the right to approach courts for their restoration; enabled large-scale preventive detention without the arrested being told the grounds; closed off judicial protection for citizens through the Supreme Court's 1976 habeas corpus ruling; and, according to the Shah Commission Report appointed later by the Janata government, made the administration and the police vulnerable to political pressure, turning them into instruments of the ruling party rather than independent institutions, a problem that did not vanish once Emergency ended.
On the positive side, the Emergency, paradoxically, demonstrated certain strengths of Indian democracy. Though many observers at the time felt India had ceased to be a democracy, normal democratic functioning resumed within a short span of time, showing how difficult it is to do away with democracy in India altogether.
It also exposed ambiguities in the Constitution's Emergency provisions that were subsequently corrected: an 'internal' Emergency can now be proclaimed only on grounds of 'armed rebellion', and the advice to the President to proclaim Emergency must be given in writing by the Union Cabinet.
Finally, the experience made citizens and the judiciary far more alert to the value of civil liberties, with courts taking a more active role afterwards in protecting individual rights, and many civil liberties organisations emerging as a direct response.
The most lasting political impact came through the ballot box: the 1977 Lok Sabha elections, held in March after the government announced fresh elections in January 1977, turned into a referendum on the experience of Emergency, especially in north India, where its effects had been felt most strongly.
The major opposition parties, which had already been coming closer before Emergency, now united to form the Janata Party under JP's leadership, joined by Congress leaders opposed to Emergency, including a group led by Jagjivan Ram that formed the Congress for Democracy and later merged into Janata.
Fighting on the slogan of 'save democracy', the Opposition won decisively: Congress fell to 154 seats and under 35 per cent of the popular vote, while Janata and its allies won 330 of 542 seats (Janata itself winning 295, a clear majority on its own).
Congress lost every seat in Bihar, Uttar Pradesh, Delhi, Haryana and Punjab, and Indira Gandhi herself was defeated in Rae Bareli, as was her son Sanjay Gandhi in Amethi.
The clear lesson, repeated in many State elections since, is that governments perceived as anti-democratic are severely punished by voters; in this sense the experience of 1975-77 ended up strengthening the foundations of Indian democracy.
Participation of different groups during this period
The crisis of 1964-1977 drew in a wide range of political and social actors, each playing a distinct role.
Students
Students were central to both the Gujarat and Bihar agitations of 1974, protesting over prices, food scarcity, unemployment and corruption; it was the Bihar students' movement that invited Jayaprakash Narayan to lead it, giving the agitation its national political character, and students' unrest from the late 1960s also fed into the atmosphere in which the Naxalite movement gathered strength.
Peasants and landless labourers
Peasants, particularly in areas of agrarian distress in West Bengal and Andhra Pradesh, were mobilised by Naxalite leaders over issues of land and debt, taking up a struggle that, unlike the JP Movement, rejected parliamentary methods altogether in favour of armed insurgency against landlords and the established order.
Industrial workers
Railway employees, through the National Coordination Committee for Railwaymen's Struggle led by George Fernandes, carried out a nationwide strike in May 1974 over bonus and service conditions, which the government declared illegal and suppressed using arrests and the territorial army, raising wider questions about the rights of workers in essential services.
Opposition political parties
Parties as ideologically different as the Socialist Party, the CPI, the Bharatiya Jana Sangh, the Bharatiya Lok Dal and Congress(O) supported JP's movement and later came together as the Janata Party, showing how the shared experience of agitation and then Emergency could unite otherwise divided opposition forces around the single goal of restoring democracy.
How did the Naxal Movement differ from the JP Movement?
Although both movements emerged from the economic distress and political discontent of the early 1970s, they differed fundamentally in method and goal.
The Naxal Movement, led by Charu Majumdar and Kanu Sanyal and concentrated among peasants in West Bengal and Andhra Pradesh, rejected parliamentary democracy altogether and took to arms to overthrow the capitalist order and the established political system.
The JP Movement, by contrast, was led by Jayaprakash Narayan among students in Gujarat and Bihar, remained committed to non-violent methods such as bandhs, gheraos, strikes and mass marches, and sought 'Total Revolution' within, rather than against, a reformed democratic framework, aiming ultimately to replace the ruling party through elections rather than insurgency.
Government responses also differed sharply: the Naxalites faced sustained police suppression through the 1970s, while the JP Movement was met, in 1975, with the much broader instrument of a national Emergency.
Timeline of key events, 1964-1980
| Year | Event |
|---|---|
| 1964 | Death of Jawaharlal Nehru; Lal Bahadur Shastri becomes Prime Minister |
| 1965 | War with Pakistan; Shastri's slogan "Jai Jawan Jai Kisan" |
| 1966 | Shastri dies in Tashkent (11 January); Indira Gandhi becomes Prime Minister |
| 1967 | Fourth general election; Congress loses power in nine States; Naxalbari uprising begins in West Bengal |
| 1969 | Congress splits into Congress(O) and Congress(R); bank nationalisation; CPI(ML) formed |
| 1971 | Fifth general election; Congress(R) restored to dominance; Bangladesh war |
| 1973 | Kesavananda Bharati case; prices rise 23 per cent; Justice A. N. Ray appointed Chief Justice |
| 1974 | Gujarat and Bihar students' agitations begin; Railway strike (May); JP's call for Total Revolution |
| 1975 | Allahabad High Court verdict against Indira Gandhi (12 June); JP's Ramlila rally (25 June); Emergency declared (25-26 June) |
| 1976 | Supreme Court upholds suspension of habeas corpus; 42nd Constitutional Amendment passed |
| 1977 | Elections announced and leaders released (January); Janata Party formed; Lok Sabha election (March); Congress defeated; Emergency withdrawn (21 March); Morarji Desai becomes Prime Minister |
| 1980 | Fresh Lok Sabha elections; Congress, led by Indira Gandhi, returns to power with 353 seats |
What do sources tell us about this period?
Much of what is known about the crisis of 1964 to 1977 comes from newspaper reporting, political cartoons and government records of the time, each of which carries its own point of view and its own limits as evidence.
Newspapers are a direct window onto the mood of the period but also show how the state tried to control that mood. Under press censorship imposed from 1975, newspapers had to obtain prior approval before publishing material; the Indian Express and the Statesman protested by leaving blank spaces where censored news had stood, a practice itself later banned, so even the blank columns of a newspaper from these years are a kind of evidence of the Emergency's reach.
Government and party documents of 1973 and 1974, such as records of the Kesavananda Bharati judgment and the Railway strike negotiations, show the official reasoning behind contested decisions, but they reflect the position of the government rather than that of its critics, so they need to be read alongside opposition statements and court rulings for balance.
The Shah Commission Report, prepared after 1977 by a commission appointed by the incoming Janata government to inquire into Emergency-era excesses, is a particularly important source because it was compiled once censorship had ended and witnesses could speak freely; it found that the administration and the police had become vulnerable to political pressure during the Emergency, turning them into instruments of the ruling party. Because it was commissioned by the Emergency's political opponents, its findings, though widely accepted, should also be weighed as the product of a particular political moment rather than a wholly neutral inquiry.
Together, newspaper columns, court judgments and later commission reports allow historians to reconstruct both what the government did during these years and how citizens and institutions experienced and resisted it.
Going beyond the syllabus
These ideas extend the unit and are not needed for the questions on it.
What happened to the Janata government after 1977?
The Janata Party government that took office in 1977 proved short-lived despite its decisive mandate: rivalry between Morarji Desai (1896-1995), Charan Singh (1902-1987) and Jagjivan Ram (1908-1986) for leadership persisted even after Desai became Prime Minister, the first non-Congress person to hold the office.
The government lost its majority in less than 28 months, and a successor government under Charan Singh, who served as Prime Minister from July 1979 to January 1980, was formed on the assurance of Congress support, but lasted only about four months before Congress withdrew that support, leading to fresh elections in January 1980.
This instability taught Indian voters another lesson in democratic politics: governments seen as unstable and quarrelsome are also severely punished at the polls, just as anti-democratic governments are.
Glossary
- Emergency: a constitutional provision (Article 352) under which the Union government can concentrate power and restrict Fundamental Rights on grounds of external threat or internal disturbance.
- Preventive detention: arresting and detaining a person not for an offence already committed but on apprehension that they may commit one.
- Habeas corpus: a legal writ by which a detained person can ask a court to examine whether their detention is lawful.
- Press censorship: requiring newspapers to obtain prior government approval before publishing material.
- Non-Congressism: Ram Manohar Lohia's strategy of uniting ideologically different non-Congress parties to defeat Congress by avoiding a split in the anti-Congress vote.
- Total Revolution: Jayaprakash Narayan's call for sweeping social, economic and political change to establish what he considered true democracy.
- Naxalite: a member of a Marxist-Leninist group that rejected parliamentary politics and took up arms against the established order, named after the Naxalbari uprising.
- Samyukt Vidhayak Dal (SVD): joint legislative parties formed by non-Congress parties after 1967 to support coalition State governments.
- Defection: an elected representative leaving the party on whose symbol they were elected and joining another party.
- Grand Alliance: the 1971 electoral alliance of major non-communist, non-Congress opposition parties formed to oppose Indira Gandhi.
- Garibi hatao: the 'remove poverty' slogan with which Congress(R) fought the 1971 election.
- Forty-second amendment: a constitutional amendment passed during Emergency, including extending legislature terms from five to six years.
- Shah Commission: a commission appointed by the Janata government after 1977 to inquire into excesses committed during Emergency.
- Congress(O) and Congress(R): the two factions formed after the 1969 Congress split, led respectively by the old 'Syndicate' and by Indira Gandhi.
Common errors and misconceptions
- Misconception: The Emergency and the Naxal Movement were the same kind of crisis for Indian democracy. Correct: The Naxal Movement was an armed insurgency against the state by a Marxist-Leninist group; the Emergency was a government-imposed suspension of democratic rights under a constitutional provision.
- Misconception: JP Narayan sought to overthrow the Constitution through 'Total Revolution'. Correct: JP sought social, economic and political change through non-violent agitation within a reformed democratic framework, not the Constitution's overthrow.
- Misconception: The 1967 election removed Congress from power nationally. Correct: Congress retained its Lok Sabha majority in 1967, though with its lowest-ever tally; it lost power only in nine States.
- Misconception: Emergency was declared because of a war or natural disaster. Correct: It was imposed in 1975 on the ground of a perceived threat of internal disturbance, under Article 352.
- Misconception: All Fundamental Rights were restored as soon as Emergency was declared over in 1977. Correct: Rights were suspended throughout the Emergency period (1975-76/77) and were restored only once it formally ended.
- Misconception: The Janata Party was a single unified party from the start. Correct: It was a coalition of several pre-existing parties, including the Jana Sangh, Bharatiya Lok Dal, Socialist Party and Congress(O), which later split apart within a few years.
- Misconception: Indira Gandhi declared Emergency immediately after the Allahabad High Court verdict. Correct: There was a gap of nearly two weeks; Emergency followed the Supreme Court's partial stay and JP's call for a satyagraha and civil disobedience by officials.
Exam-style questions with model answers
Q1. Who among the following Prime Ministers coined the slogan "Jai Jawan, Jai Kisan"? [1 mark]
- (a) Jawaharlal Nehru
- (b) Indira Gandhi
- (c) Morarji Desai
- (d) Lal Bahadur Shastri
- Answer: (d) Lal Bahadur Shastri.
Q2. Read the two statements and choose the correct option. Assertion: The Emergency of 1975 was proclaimed on the ground of a perceived threat of internal disturbance. Reason: The proclamation was issued by President Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed on the night of 25 June 1975. [1 mark]
- (a) Both Assertion and Reason are true and Reason is the correct explanation for Assertion.
- (b) Both Assertion and Reason are true but Reason is not the correct explanation for Assertion.
- (c) Assertion is true and Reason is false.
- (d) Both Assertion and Reason are false.
- Answer: (b). Both statements are true, but the Reason states how the proclamation was issued, not why it was issued.
Q3. Name the leader who led the Railway employees' nationwide strike of May 1974 and the body that called it. [2 marks]
- The strike was called by the National Coordination Committee for Railwaymen's Struggle.
- It was led by George Fernandes, and the employees struck work over bonus and service conditions.
Q4. State any four reasons for the importance of the general election of 1967. [4 marks]
- Congress won its lowest tally of Lok Sabha seats and share of votes since 1952, ending its uncontested dominance.
- Congress lost power altogether in nine States, including Punjab, Bihar, Uttar Pradesh and West Bengal.
- The DMK, a regional party, won a clear majority on its own in Madras State, the first time any non-Congress party had done so in a State.
- The election introduced coalition SVD governments and frequent defections, symbolised by the phrase "Aya Ram, Gaya Ram".
Q5. Explain the main features of the suspension of democratic rights during the Emergency of 1975-76. [4 marks]
- The federal distribution of powers was practically suspended and all powers concentrated in the union government.
- Fundamental Rights stood suspended, including the right of citizens to move the Court for restoring them.
- Press censorship was imposed, requiring prior approval for publication, and organisations such as the RSS and Jamait-e-Islami were banned.
- Preventive detention was used on a large scale, and arrested persons could not successfully challenge their detention through habeas corpus petitions.
Q6. Distinguish between the ideology and methods of the CPI and the CPI(M) in this period. [4 marks]
- The CPI worked largely within the parliamentary system and was willing to support Indira Gandhi's government on particular issues, allying with Congress(R) in the 1971 election.
- The CPI(M) took a more radical left position, holding that parliamentary politics alone could not end the power of big business and landlords.
- The CPI(M) insisted on mass struggles of workers and peasants alongside electoral work.
- Groups that rejected parliamentary politics altogether broke away in the late 1960s and became the Naxalite or Marxist-Leninist groups.
Q7. Discuss the factors that led to the rise of the Naxal Movement and the measures taken by the government against it. [8 marks]
- The movement grew out of agrarian inequality, falling agricultural output after poor monsoons and high inflation, which created distress among landless peasants and sharecroppers.
- Students' unrest that had persisted since the late 1960s fed into the atmosphere of radical, non-parliamentary politics.
- It began with the uprising at Naxalbari in West Bengal in 1967 and was led by Charu Majumdar and Kanu Sanyal, who organised peasants against landlords and moneylenders over land and debt.
- Student groups in Calcutta and other parts of West Bengal joined, giving the movement both a peasant and a student base.
- It spread to areas of West Bengal and Andhra Pradesh, where similar agrarian unrest among sharecroppers and landless labourers provided fertile ground.
- Charu Majumdar formed the Communist Party of India (Marxist-Leninist) in 1969, committed to armed struggle rather than elections.
- The West Bengal government took stringent measures to suppress the movement, including police action against its cadres and its peasant and student bases.
- The movement declined in the 1970s through sustained police action, the death of Charu Majumdar in 1972 and internal splits among Naxalite factions over strategy and ideology.
Q8. Assess the significance of the JP Movement of 1974-75. [8 marks]
- It grew out of student protests in Gujarat in January 1974 and in Bihar in March 1974 against rising prices, food scarcity, unemployment and corruption.
- The Bihar students invited Jayaprakash Narayan to lead them, and he accepted on condition that the movement remain non-violent and not be limited to Bihar.
- This gave the students' protest a political character and national appeal, and JP called for 'Total Revolution' in the social, economic and political spheres.
- The movement spread through bandhs, gheraos and strikes, and the Railway strike of May 1974 led by George Fernandes added to the atmosphere of labour unrest.
- In 1975 JP led a people's march to Parliament, one of the largest political rallies ever held in the capital.
- It brought together ideologically diverse non-Congress parties, including the Bharatiya Jana Sangh, Congress(O), the Bharatiya Lok Dal and the Socialist Party, around a common platform.
- It made JP a national symbol of resistance and became the moving force behind the formation of the Janata Party.
- It also drew criticism for the politics of mass agitation it employed and for asking government employees and the army to disobey orders, which some saw as a threat to ordered constitutional government.
Q9. Assess the positive and negative impact of the Emergency on Indian democracy. [8 marks]
- Negatively, it suspended Fundamental Rights and allowed large-scale preventive detention without the arrested being told the grounds.
- It closed judicial protection for citizens, since the Supreme Court in 1976 accepted that even the right to life and liberty could be taken away during Emergency.
- According to the Shah Commission, the administration and the police became vulnerable to political pressure and were turned into instruments of the ruling party.
- Positively, normal democratic functioning resumed within a short span after the Emergency ended, showing how difficult it is to do away with democracy in India.
- Ambiguities in the Constitution's Emergency provisions were corrected: an internal Emergency can now be proclaimed only on grounds of armed rebellion, and the advice to the President must be given in writing by the Union Cabinet.
- Citizens and the judiciary became more alert to civil liberties, and many civil liberties organisations emerged.
- The 1977 election became a referendum on the Emergency, and the voters decisively rejected the Congress, which fell to 154 seats and under 35 per cent of the vote.
- The lesson that governments perceived as anti-democratic are severely punished by voters strengthened the foundations of Indian democracy.
Key takeaways
- Lal Bahadur Shastri's peaceful succession after Nehru and his slogan "Jai Jawan Jai Kisan" showed democratic maturity amid war and food crisis.
- The 1967 election ended uncontested Congress dominance, costing it power in nine States and introducing coalition and defection politics.
- Opposition parties such as the Socialist Party, CPI, CPI(M), Jan Sangh and Akali Dal held very different ideologies, making most anti-Congress coalitions fragile.
- The Naxal Movement rejected parliamentary politics for armed peasant insurgency, centred in West Bengal and Andhra Pradesh, and declined through repression, leadership loss and internal splits.
- The JP Movement grew from student protests in Gujarat and Bihar into a national non-violent campaign for 'Total Revolution' against Indira Gandhi's government.
- The Allahabad High Court's 1975 verdict against Indira Gandhi, followed by JP's call for satyagraha, directly triggered the declaration of Emergency.
- Emergency suspended Fundamental Rights, imposed press censorship and preventive detention, and extended the Lok Sabha's term through the 42nd amendment.
- The 1977 election became a referendum on Emergency, leading to Congress's first-ever defeat and the formation of the Janata government under Morarji Desai.
Test yourself
Who succeeded Jawaharlal Nehru as Prime Minister, and what slogan is he remembered for?
Lal Bahadur Shastri succeeded Nehru in 1964 and is remembered for the slogan "Jai Jawan Jai Kisan".
What was 'non-Congressism', and who proposed it?
Non-Congressism was Ram Manohar Lohia's strategy of uniting ideologically different non-Congress parties to defeat Congress without dividing the anti-Congress vote.
Name the two leaders most associated with the Naxal Movement.
Charu Majumdar and Kanu Sanyal.
What did Jayaprakash Narayan call for during the Bihar movement?
He called for 'Total Revolution' in the social, economic and political spheres to establish true democracy, and demanded the Bihar government's dismissal.
Under which Article of the Constitution was the Emergency of 1975 declared?
Article 352, on grounds of a perceived threat of internal disturbance.
What change did the 42nd amendment make to the Lok Sabha's term?
It extended the duration of legislatures from five to six years, a change intended to be permanent, not just for the Emergency period.
Which party won the 1977 Lok Sabha election, and who became Prime Minister?
The Janata Party and its allies won 330 of 542 seats; Morarji Desai became Prime Minister.
What did the Bharatiya Jan Sangh stand for?
It stood for cultural nationalism, drew support from the Hindi-speaking north, urban middle classes and traders, and opposed Kashmir's special status, pressing for a uniform civil code and a ban on cow slaughter.
What did the Shiromani Akali Dal demand?
It combined Sikh religious and cultural identity with regional autonomy, arguing that Punjab had been treated unfairly in river waters and resources and demanding greater powers for the States.
Write about it
Turn a question from this chapter into a paper.
The Writing Studio has a structure guide, a rubric and citation tools for 15 formats, from essays to research papers. A free account keeps up to five drafts. Learnacy Essential adds feedback from an AI writing coach and submission to The OYI Review.
Publication depends on review and is not guaranteed.
