Entrepreneurship in Action, 21-24 Nov, online. Build a working product with AI

Introduction to Political Science and State | ISC Class 11 Political Science Notes

18 min read

On this page

This note covers the meaning of political science in its classical and modern senses, why politics matters, the difference between politics and political science, the scope of contemporary political science through political theory, comparative politics, international relations, public administration and political economy, the meaning of the state and its four elements, and the difference between state and nation.

What is politics, and why does it matter?

People hold very different ideas of what politics is. Some leaders call it public service; others link it with manipulation, intrigue and scams. When people use any means to promote their interests, we say they are "playing politics", and many say they want to stay away from it.

Yet politics is an important and integral part of any society. Mahatma Gandhi once observed that politics envelops us like the coils of a snake and there is no way out but to wrestle with it. No society can exist without some form of political organisation and collective decision making.

Governments play an important part in this. Their economic, foreign and educational policies can improve people's lives, while an inefficient or corrupt government can endanger them. Because government actions affect us deeply, we form associations, organise campaigns, negotiate, protest and debate in order to shape what governments do.

Politics therefore arises from the fact that people have different visions of what is just and desirable. It involves the many negotiations through which collective decisions are made: what governments do and how they relate to people's aspirations, and how people struggle to influence decision making.

Definition: Politics. Politics is the activity through which people with different interests and visions negotiate, take part in collective activities and make collective decisions, especially about what governments do.

What does political science mean in the classical sense?

Political science is the systematic study of politics, the state and government. The subject is very old. As far back as the fifth and fourth centuries B.C., Plato and Aristotle discussed with their students whether monarchy or democracy was better, and in India Kautilya wrote on statecraft.

The word politics comes from the Greek polis, the city-state. Aristotle, often called the father of political science, wrote a work called Politics and held that man is by nature a political animal, who can live a full life only in a political community.

In the classical or traditional sense, political science is the study of the state and government: their origin, nature, purposes, institutions and forms. The American political scientist J. W. Garner summed up this view by saying that political science begins and ends with the state.

The classical approach was largely philosophical, historical and legal. It asked what the best state is, how states have developed, and how constitutions and laws distribute power. It tended to concentrate on formal institutions such as legislatures, executives and courts, and on the ideals they should serve.

Aristotle also gave the subject its comparative method. He and his students are said to have collected and studied the constitutions of 158 Greek city-states, and from them he classified governments by who rules (one, few or many) and whether they rule for the common good or for themselves.

How do modern political scientists define the subject?

In the twentieth century many political scientists felt the classical approach was too narrow. They argued that politics happens not only in formal institutions but wherever people compete for power and influence, including in political parties, pressure groups, elections and public opinion.

The modern view treats political science as the study of power, authority and political behaviour. The American political scientist Harold Lasswell defined politics as the study of who gets what, when and how. David Easton described the political system as the authoritative allocation of values for a society.

Modern political science also became more empirical. It uses observation, surveys, statistics and comparison to study how people actually behave in politics, for example why voters choose particular parties or why some governments are more stable than others.

The two views complement each other. The classical view reminds us of the ideals and institutions of the state, while the modern view shows how power is actually exercised and contested in society. Contemporary political science draws on both.

Politics versus political science: how do they differ?

The two terms are often used as if they meant the same thing, but they are different. Politics is an activity: the process of negotiation, competition and decision making in society. Political science is the systematic study of that activity.

BasisPoliticsPolitical science
NatureA practical activity and processAn academic discipline
Who engages in itLeaders, parties, groups and citizensStudents, scholars and researchers
AimTo influence collective decisions and gain or use powerTo understand, explain and evaluate political life
MethodNegotiation, campaigns, elections, protestSystematic study, analysis and comparison
ValuesOften driven by interests and partisanshipAims at objectivity and reasoned judgement

The two are closely linked. Political science draws its material from the practice of politics, and good political practice can draw on the knowledge that political science produces about institutions, elections and public policy. A citizen who understands political science is better able to judge the claims made in everyday politics.

A politician practises politics; a political scientist studies it. Studying political science does not make a person a politician, but it helps every citizen think rationally about political questions and assess the political events of the time.

What is the scope of contemporary political science?

Contemporary political science has grown into a broad discipline with several main branches. Five of them are especially important: political theory, comparative politics, international relations, public administration and political economy.

These branches overlap. A question such as how India should reduce poverty involves values (political theory), comparison with other countries (comparative politics), foreign aid and trade (international relations), the delivery of schemes (public administration) and the working of markets (political economy).

Together they show that political science studies not only the state but the whole range of activities through which power is gained, used and limited, inside countries and between them.

The scope of the subject widened a great deal after the Second World War. In the 1950s and 1960s the behavioural movement, strong in the United States, urged political scientists to study the actual behaviour of voters, leaders and groups through scientific methods rather than only formal institutions and legal rules.

Later, the post-behavioural approach, associated with David Easton, argued that research must also be relevant to society's real problems and lead to action. Today political science combines the study of values, institutions and behaviour, which is why its scope is described as broad and still growing.

What do political theory and comparative politics mean?

Political theory deals systematically with the ideas and principles that shape constitutions, governments and social life. It clarifies the meaning of concepts such as freedom, equality, justice, democracy and secularism, and probes principles such as the rule of law, separation of powers and judicial review.

It examines the arguments of thinkers from Kautilya, Plato and Aristotle to Rousseau, Marx, Gandhi and Ambedkar. Rousseau first argued for freedom as a fundamental right of humankind; Marx argued that equality was as crucial as freedom.

Gandhi discussed genuine freedom or swaraj in Hind Swaraj; and Ambedkar argued that the scheduled castes must receive special protection as a minority.

The objective of political theory is to train citizens to think rationally about political questions. It remains relevant because rights such as freedom are continually reinterpreted; for example, courts have interpreted the right to life to include the right to livelihood.

Comparative politics studies and compares political systems, institutions and processes in different countries. It asks, for example, how a parliamentary system such as India's differs from a presidential system such as that of the USA, or why democracy has lasted in some countries and failed in others.

Comparison helps us see what is general and what is unique in each system.

What do international relations, public administration and political economy mean?

International relations studies the relations among states and other actors in world politics: diplomacy, war and peace, alliances, trade, international organisations such as the United Nations, and global problems such as terrorism and climate change. It explains how states pursue their interests and how conflict and cooperation arise among them.

The most important international organisation is the United Nations, founded in 1945 after the Second World War to maintain international peace and security. Almost every state in the world is a member, and the study of its working is a central part of international relations.

Public administration studies how government policies are implemented. It deals with the organisation and working of the bureaucracy, the civil services, budgeting, planning and the delivery of public services, asking how government can be made efficient, accountable and responsive to citizens.

Political economy studies the interaction between politics and economics: how political decisions shape economic outcomes such as growth, inequality and trade, and how economic interests and markets influence political power. Questions about taxation, welfare and the role of the state in the economy belong to it.

These branches give political science its breadth. Each focuses on a different part of political life, but all share the aim of understanding how societies make and carry out collective decisions.

Why should we study political science today?

One might ask whether political science is still relevant once a country has achieved freedom and democracy. It is, because questions of freedom, equality and democracy keep arising in many areas of social life, and they are realised in different sectors at different paces.

For instance, equality may exist in the political sphere in the form of equal rights, yet people may still be discriminated against socially because of their caste or poverty. Some enjoy privilege while others lack even basic necessities, so for many, freedom is still a distant dream.

Second, rights are constantly reinterpreted, much as players learn new meanings of the rules of chess or cricket as they play. The right to life has been interpreted by the courts to include the right to livelihood, and the right to information has been granted through a new law.

Third, a changing world brings new dimensions of freedom and new threats to it. Global communications help activists protect tribal cultures or forests, but also help terrorists and criminals network. Online shopping requires that the information we give about ourselves be protected, raising the question of how much regulation of the internet is justified and who should regulate it.

Political science helps us think through such questions rationally, weigh competing arguments fairly, and take part in public life as informed and responsible citizens.

What is the state?

The state is the central concept of political science. In everyday speech the word is used loosely, for example for the states of the Indian Union, but in political science it has a precise meaning.

The state is a political community of people living in a definite territory, organised under a government, and possessing sovereignty, that is, supreme power within its territory and independence from external control.

In international law, the Montevideo Convention of 1933 similarly identified a permanent population, a defined territory, a government and the capacity to enter into relations with other states.

Definition: State. The state is a community of people occupying a definite territory, organised under a government, and possessing sovereignty, both internal supremacy and external independence.

The states of the Indian Union, such as Kerala or Punjab, are not states in this sense, because they are not sovereign: they are units of a larger federal state. India as a whole is the state in the political science sense.

The state must also be distinguished from the government. Government is only one element of the state, the machinery through which the state acts. Governments change, as one party replaces another after an election, but the state continues. Sovereignty belongs to the state, while the government exercises it on the state's behalf for a time.

What are the four elements of the state?

A state has four essential elements. If any one is missing, there is no state:

  1. Population: a state needs people. There is no fixed number; states range from very small populations to well over a billion people, as in India and China.
  2. Territory: a state needs a definite territory with recognised boundaries, including its land, inland waters, territorial waters and the airspace above them.
  3. Government: a state needs an organised government, the agency through which the will of the state is formulated, expressed and carried out; it usually has a legislature, an executive and a judiciary.
  4. Sovereignty: a state must be sovereign, possessing supreme power within its territory and independence from outside control.

Of the four elements, sovereignty is the most important, because it distinguishes the state from all other associations. A university, a trade union or a company may have members, a place and an organisation, but none of them is sovereign.

Sovereignty has two aspects. Internal sovereignty means the state's supreme authority over all persons and associations within its territory. External sovereignty means its independence from the control of any other state. India became independent on 15 August 1947, as a dominion with the British King still its formal head of state, and a sovereign democratic republic on 26 January 1950.

Territory today extends beyond land. Under international law a coastal state's territorial waters extend up to 12 nautical miles from its coast, and the state also controls the airspace above its land and territorial waters. This is why violations of airspace or territorial waters are treated as violations of sovereignty.

State versus nation: how do they differ?

The words state and nation are often used together, as in nation-state, but they mean different things.

A nation is a people bound together by a sense of common identity, built on shared history, culture, language, traditions or aspirations, and a desire to live together. A state is a political organisation with population, territory, government and sovereignty.

BasisStateNation
NatureA political and legal organisationA psychological and cultural community
Essential elementsPopulation, territory, government, sovereigntyA sense of common identity and unity
TerritoryMust have a definite territoryNeed not have a territory of its own
SovereigntyMust be sovereignNeed not be sovereign
Basis of unityLaw and the authority of governmentShared feelings, culture and history

A nation may exist without a state of its own. The Polish nation, for example, survived when Poland was partitioned in 1795 and had no state until 1918. A state may also contain many nationalities, as the former Soviet Union did, which is why such states are called multinational.

When the boundaries of a nation and a state coincide, the result is a nation-state. India is often described as a state-nation, in which a single state holds together many languages, religions and cultures within a shared national identity.

Glossary

  • Politics: the activity of negotiation and collective decision making in society, especially concerning what governments do.
  • Political science: the systematic study of politics, the state, government, power and political behaviour.
  • Polis: the Greek city-state, from which the word politics comes.
  • Political theory: the branch that clarifies political ideas and principles such as freedom, equality and justice.
  • Comparative politics: the branch that compares political systems, institutions and processes across countries.
  • International relations: the branch that studies relations among states and other actors in world politics.
  • Public administration: the branch that studies how government policies are implemented.
  • Political economy: the branch that studies the interaction between politics and economics.
  • State: a political community with population, territory, government and sovereignty.
  • Sovereignty: supreme power within a territory and independence from external control.
  • Nation: a people bound by a sense of common identity and a desire to live together.
  • Nation-state: a state whose boundaries coincide with those of a nation.

Common errors and misconceptions

  • Misconception: politics is only about scams and selfish manipulation. Correct: politics is an integral part of society through which collective decisions are made and a better world can be pursued.
  • Misconception: politics and political science mean the same thing. Correct: politics is an activity; political science is the systematic study of that activity.
  • Misconception: the states of the Indian Union are states in the political science sense. Correct: they lack sovereignty; India as a whole is the state.
  • Misconception: government and state are the same. Correct: government is only one element of the state, the agency through which its will is carried out.
  • Misconception: every nation has a state of its own. Correct: a nation may exist without a state, as the Polish nation did between 1795 and 1918.
  • Misconception: modern political science studies only formal institutions. Correct: it also studies power, political behaviour, parties, groups and public opinion.

Exam-style questions with model answers

Q1. Name the element of the state that distinguishes it from all other associations. [1 mark]
  1. Sovereignty, the supreme power within the territory and independence from external control.
Q2. Distinguish between the classical and the modern meaning of political science. [2 marks]
  1. The classical meaning treats political science as the study of the state and government, their origin, nature, institutions and ideals.
  2. The modern meaning treats it as the study of power, authority and political behaviour, using empirical methods.
Q3. What is meant by comparative politics? [2 marks]
  1. Comparative politics studies and compares political systems, institutions and processes in different countries.
  2. For example, it compares India's parliamentary system with the presidential system of the USA.
Q4. Explain the four elements of the state. [4 marks]
  1. Population: a state needs people, though there is no fixed number.
  2. Territory: it needs a definite territory with recognised boundaries, including land, waters and airspace.
  3. Government: it needs an organised government through which its will is formulated and carried out.
  4. Sovereignty: it must have supreme internal power and external independence.
Q5. Distinguish between state and nation on any four bases. [4 marks]
  1. The state is a political and legal organisation; the nation is a psychological and cultural community.
  2. The state must have territory; a nation need not have a territory of its own.
  3. The state must be sovereign; a nation need not be sovereign.
  4. The state is held together by law and government; a nation by shared feelings, culture and history.
Q6. Explain the scope of contemporary political science with reference to its five main branches. [8 marks]
  1. Contemporary political science studies the whole range of activities through which power is gained, used and limited.
  2. Political theory clarifies ideas and principles such as freedom, equality, justice and democracy.
  3. Comparative politics compares political systems, institutions and processes across countries.
  4. International relations studies relations among states, diplomacy, war and peace, and international organisations.
  5. Public administration studies how policies are implemented through the bureaucracy and public services.
  6. Political economy studies how politics and economics influence each other.
  7. The branches overlap, as a problem such as poverty involves all of them.
  8. Together they make political science a broad discipline that helps citizens think rationally about political life.
Q7. How does politics differ from political science? [2 marks]
  1. Politics is a practical activity of negotiation and decision making carried on by leaders, parties and citizens.
  2. Political science is an academic discipline that systematically studies and explains that activity.

Key takeaways

  • Politics is an integral part of society: the process through which people negotiate and make collective decisions.
  • In the classical sense, political science is the study of the state and government, going back to Plato and Aristotle.
  • In the modern sense, it is the study of power, authority and political behaviour, using empirical methods.
  • Politics is an activity; political science is the systematic study of that activity.
  • Contemporary political science includes political theory, comparative politics, international relations, public administration and political economy.
  • The state has four elements: population, territory, government and sovereignty.
  • Sovereignty, internal and external, is the element that distinguishes the state from other associations.
  • A nation is a community of common identity; it may exist without a state, and a state may contain many nationalities.

Test yourself

From which Greek word does politics come?

From polis, the Greek word for the city-state, which Plato and Aristotle studied.

What did Gandhi say about politics?

He observed that politics envelops us like the coils of a snake and there is no way out but to wrestle with it.

How did Harold Lasswell define politics?

He defined politics as the study of who gets what, when and how in a society.

What does public administration study?

It studies how government policies are implemented through the bureaucracy, civil services and public services.

What is internal sovereignty?

The supreme authority of the state over all persons and associations within its territory.

Why is Kerala not a state in the political science sense?

Because it lacks sovereignty; it is a unit of the Indian Union, which is the sovereign state.

Give an example of a nation without a state.

The Polish nation between 1795 and 1918, when Poland was partitioned and had no state of its own.

What is a nation-state?

A state whose boundaries coincide with those of a nation, bound by a common identity.

Take this further

How does India make policy?

The Model NITI Aayog self-paced course: 41 chapters, about 18 hours of study, on how India makes policy, from the policy cycle and writing a white paper to the economy, the Union Budget and governance. It comes with the live Model NITI Aayog programme.

Learnacy Essential adds feedback from an AI writing coach, submission to The OYI Review, 10 self-paced courses, World 101’s member tools and the 3D labs. Publication is not guaranteed. See what membership includes

Or create a free account to draft in the Writing Studio, explore World 101’s map and open the 2D version of every lab. Create a free account