Kabir and His Poetry as a Source | CBSE Class 12 History Notes
On this page
Part of: Bhakti-Sufi Traditions (CBSE Class 12 History, Themes in Indian History Part II, Theme 6). This page goes deeper into one section of that chapter note: how Kabir questioned religious divisions. It treats the verses ascribed to him as historical evidence.
Who was Kabir, and how much can historians know about his life?
NCERT dates Kabir to c. fourteenth to fifteenth centuries, and its timeline lists him for c. 1400 to 1500, beside Raidas and Surdas in Uttar Pradesh. NCERT suggests he was perhaps one of the most outstanding poet-saints of the period.
Other scholars place him later. Charlotte Vaudeville (1987) puts his birth near the middle of the fifteenth century. W. H. McLeod's review (1992) reports that David Lorenzen (1991) set his dates in the late fifteenth and early sixteenth centuries. The Concise Oxford Dictionary of World Religions gives his death as 1518; NCERT prints no year.
Vaudeville describes him as born a Julaha, a low-caste Muslim weaver. She judged that he was probably illiterate and wrote nothing down himself. Hess and Singh (2002) call him an oral poet whose works others recorded, so every account of his life rests on later texts.
What do the hagiographies claim, and when were they written?
A hagiography is a life of a saint written by devotees. NCERT reports that many lives of Kabir date from the seventeenth century onwards, about two centuries after him, and carry later debates over whether he was born a Hindu or a Muslim.
In the Vaishnava version NCERT summarises, he is born a Hindu, Kabirdas, raised by poor Muslim julahas and initiated into bhakti by a guru, perhaps Ramananda. NCERT adds that "Kabir" is an Arabic word meaning "great".
Vaudeville (1987) retells a death legend: Hindus and Muslims both claimed his body at Magahar, found only flowers, and divided them, one side burying and the other cremating its share.
The earliest known collection of legends, says the publisher of Lorenzen's book (1991), is Anantadas's Kabir Parachai. McLeod (1992) dates it towards the end of the sixteenth century and finds that it reveals very little about Kabir's actual life.
Which three traditions preserve the verses ascribed to Kabir?
NCERT describes three compilations that are distinct but overlapping, all made long after Kabir died. Vaudeville (1987) calls them recensions, or versions of one body of text.
The Kabir Bijak is kept by the Kabirpanth, "the path or sect of Kabir" in NCERT's gloss, in Varanasi and elsewhere in Uttar Pradesh. Vaudeville calls it the eastern recension, spread, if not compiled, in Bihar; she adds that Kabir himself founded no sect.
NCERT links the Kabir Granthavali with the Dadupanth of Rajasthan, whose collections, the Panchavanis, Vaudeville dates to c. 1600. Many compositions also sit in the Adi Granth Sahib, which Guru Arjan compiled with the hymns of Guru Nanak and other poets.
| Collection | Who keeps it | Region | What it shows |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kabir Bijak | Kabirpanth (NCERT) | Varanasi and Uttar Pradesh (NCERT); Bihar (Vaudeville) | The eastern recension; the sect's sacred book (Vaudeville; Hess and Singh) |
| Kabir Granthavali | Dadupanth (NCERT) | Rajasthan (NCERT) | Verses gathered in the Panchavanis, c. 1600 (Vaudeville) |
| Adi Granth Sahib | Sikh tradition (Vaudeville; Kohli) | Amritsar, Punjab (Kohli; Vaudeville) | The oldest dated record of Kabir's words (Vaudeville) |
Surindar Singh Kohli (1987) dates the Adi Granth to 1604 at Amritsar. NCERT notes that by the nineteenth century, printed anthologies of his verses circulated in Bengal, Gujarat and Maharashtra, and that several groups claimed his legacy and still remember him.
In which languages and forms do the verses survive?
NCERT says the poems survive in several languages and dialects, some in sant bhasha, the special language of nirguna poets. Vaudeville (1987) calls his language a nondescript form of Old Hindi, perhaps a common tongue of wandering holy men.
Hess and Singh (2002) name three forms: the shabda or pada, a song; the sakhi or doha, a two-line saying of popular wisdom; and the ramaini. Vaudeville describes padas as short songs set to a refrain.
The ulatbansi, NCERT's "upside-down sayings", inverts everyday sense. Images such as "the lotus which blooms without flower", NCERT suggests, show how hard it is to put the Ultimate Reality into words.
The verses were also sung. A seventeenth-century Mughal painting of roadside musicians in NCERT carries a caption suggesting the sants' songs were sung by such performers. Vaudeville notes imitation and interpolation before the verses were written down.
How do the verses name the Ultimate Reality?
NCERT lists Islamic names (Allah, Khuda, Pir and Hazrat), Vedantic terms (nirakar, the formless; alakh, the unseen; Atman and Brahman) and yogic terms (shunya, emptiness, and shabda, sound).
NCERT links Kabir with the nirguna poets. It explains that historians of religion divide bhakti into saguna (with attributes) and nirguna (without attributes), nirguna bhakti being worship of an abstract form of god. For Vaudeville (1987), names such as Hari and Ram point to a reality beyond words, often identified with shunya, the void.
Source box: a composition attributed to Kabir, in the translation NCERT prints, Themes in Indian History Part II, Theme 6, Source 10 (reprint 2026-27). "God is called by many names: Names like Allah, Ram, Karim, Keshav, Hari, and Hazrat."
What it shows: Islamic and Hindu names stand side by side as names of one God. NCERT asks the student what argument Kabir makes against separating the gods of different communities.
The same composition compares the names to gold worked into rings and bangles: the shapes differ, the metal does not. Later it says both sides are mistaken.
How do the verses treat ritual and religious divisions?
NCERT stresses diverse and sometimes conflicting ideas. Some poems, it says, use Islamic belief in one God and the rejection of images to attack the worship of many gods and of idols. Others use the Sufi zikr, reciting the Divine Names, and ishq, love, to express nam-simaran, remembering God's name.
Source box: the close of the same composition, in NCERT's translation, Theme 6, Source 10. "One kills the goat, the other cows. They waste their lives in disputation."
What it shows: the verse criticises both groups at once and calls their quarrel wasted effort; historians then interpret that position.
Historians differ on how far this went. Vaudeville (1987) argued that Kabir rejected "the two religions" outright, attacked pandits and mullahs alike, and accepted no revealed scripture, neither Veda nor Qur'an. NCERT stresses exchange: his ideas probably took shape through dialogue and debate with Sufis and yogis in Awadh.
Were all these verses composed by Kabir, and was Ramananda his guru?
NCERT says it may never be possible to tell with certainty which verses are Kabir's. Scholars test language, style and content. Vaudeville (1987) adds that no fully authoritative version exists and that only a comparison of the three main recensions gives a fair idea of his teaching.
The corpus grew. Hess and Singh (2002) note that thousands of poems are popularly attributed to Kabir, while few written collections survive. Vaudeville's bibliography lists a critical edition by Parasnath Tiwari (Allahabad, 1965).
On Ramananda, NCERT points out that the verses use the words guru and satguru but name no teacher. Historians find it very hard to make the two contemporaries without improbably long lives; NCERT's timeline lists Ramananda for c. 1300 to 1400.
Scholars divide. Vaudeville read the satguru as the One who speaks within the soul, not any human guru. Lorenzen (1991), as McLeod (1992) reports, argued that the discipleship claim can probably be sustained. NCERT concludes that such traditions cannot be taken at face value, yet they show how much Kabir's legacy mattered to later generations.
How do historians use Kabir's verses as a source?
Verses, even of uncertain authorship, show which ideas circulated under Kabir's name. Hagiographies show how later communities wished to remember him.
| Evidence | What it can show | Its limits | Judgement from |
|---|---|---|---|
| Verses in the three collections | Ideas and vocabulary from Islamic, Vedantic and yogic traditions | Compiled long after his death; authorship uncertain | NCERT; Vaudeville |
| Adi Granth Sahib | A dated written text of his words | Still compiled long after his lifetime | Kohli; Vaudeville |
| Hagiographies | How devotees claimed him | Many written about two centuries later; little biography | NCERT; McLeod |
A careful answer keeps the two apart. It checks a verse across the collections, and treats a story such as the flowers at Magahar as evidence of later memory rather than at face value.
The CBSE syllabus for 2026-27 asks the student to summarise the philosophies of bhakti and Sufi saints, and lists "The Vision of Kabir" among suggested projects. Such a project can follow this method.
Timeline: how did the record of Kabir take shape, from c. 1300 to the present syllabus?
The rows mix lifetimes, compilations and editions, which are different kinds of evidence.
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| c. 1300 to 1400 | Ramananda in Uttar Pradesh (NCERT's timeline) |
| c. 1400 to 1500 | Kabir, with Raidas and Surdas (NCERT's timeline) |
| Mid-fifteenth century | Kabir's birth, in Vaudeville's dating |
| 1518 | Kabir's death (Concise Oxford Dictionary of World Religions) |
| Late sixteenth century | Anantadas writes the Kabir Parachai (McLeod) |
| c. 1600 | Dadupanthi Panchavanis compiled in Rajasthan (Vaudeville) |
| 1604 | Guru Arjan compiles the Adi Granth at Amritsar (Kohli) |
| Seventeenth century onwards | Many hagiographies of Kabir composed (NCERT) |
| Nineteenth century | Printed anthologies circulate in Bengal, Gujarat and Maharashtra (NCERT) |
| 1928 | Shyam Sundar Das's Kabir Granthavali printed at Banaras (Vaudeville's bibliography) |
| 1983 | Hess and Singh's English translation of the Bijak appears; Oxford University Press publishes it in 2002 |
| 2026-27 | CBSE lists "The Vision of Kabir" as a project |
Sources: which records and studies support this page?
- NCERT, Themes in Indian History Part II, Theme 6, "Bhakti-Sufi Traditions", reprint 2026-27: section 8.1, Source 10, Fig. 6.16 and the timeline (c. 1300 to 1400; c. 1400 to 1500).
- CBSE, History syllabus, Class 12, 2026-27: Theme 6 learning objectives, project 15, "The Vision of Kabir", and the 1, 3, 4 and 8 mark design.
- Charlotte Vaudeville, "Kabir", Encyclopedia of Religion, 1987, with revised bibliography, on Encyclopedia.com, consulted November 2026 (c. 1600; around 1604; Das, 1928; Tiwari, 1965; Hess and Singh, 1983).
- Surindar Singh Kohli, "Adi Granth", Encyclopedia of Religion, 1987, on Encyclopedia.com, consulted November 2026 (1604, Amritsar).
- Linda Hess and Shukdeo Singh, The Bijak of Kabir, Oxford University Press, 2002; book abstract on Oxford Academic, online 2003.
- David N. Lorenzen, Kabir Legends and Ananta-Das's Kabir Parachai, SUNY Press, 1991, publisher's description.
- W. H. McLeod, review of Lorenzen, Journal of the American Oriental Society 112, no. 3, July 1992, excerpt on vLex.
- John Bowker (ed.), The Concise Oxford Dictionary of World Religions, "Kabir", on Encyclopedia.com, consulted November 2026 (died 1518).
Glossary
- Kabirpanth: "the path or sect of Kabir" in NCERT's gloss; it preserves the Kabir Bijak in Varanasi and elsewhere in Uttar Pradesh.
- Dadupanth: a devotional community of Rajasthan that NCERT links with the Kabir Granthavali; Vaudeville dates its Panchavanis to c. 1600.
- Sant bhasha: the special language of the nirguna poets, in NCERT's description, used in some verses ascribed to Kabir.
- Ulatbansi: an "upside-down saying" that inverts everyday meanings to hint at a reality words cannot easily capture.
- Sakhi: a two-line saying, also called a doha, which Hess and Singh (2002) link with popular wisdom across north India.
- Nirguna: "without attributes"; NCERT describes nirguna bhakti as worship of an abstract form of god.
- Satguru: a title for the guru in the verses, which name no teacher; Vaudeville (1987) read it as the One who speaks within the soul.
Common errors and misconceptions
- Misconception: Kabir wrote his poems down himself. Correct: Vaudeville (1987) judged he wrote nothing, and NCERT says the compilations came long after his death.
- Misconception: The three collections contain the same verses. Correct: NCERT calls them distinct but overlapping; Vaudeville says only comparing all three gives a fair picture.
- Misconception: Historians agree that Ramananda was Kabir's guru. Correct: NCERT finds them hard to make contemporaries; Lorenzen (1991) argues the claim can probably be sustained.
- Misconception: The hagiographies are eyewitness biographies. Correct: NCERT dates many to the seventeenth century onwards; McLeod (1992) says the Kabir Parachai reveals little of his life.
- Misconception: Every verse ascribed to Kabir expresses one consistent view. Correct: NCERT notes conflicting ideas, some drawing on Islamic monotheism and others on Sufi zikr and ishq.
Exam-style questions with model answers
Q1. Which compilation of verses ascribed to Kabir does NCERT associate with the Dadupanth in Rajasthan? (a) Kabir Bijak (b) Kabir Granthavali (c) Adi Granth Sahib (d) Kabir Parachai [1 mark]
(b) Kabir Granthavali. NCERT links it with the Dadupanth of Rajasthan, and Vaudeville (1987) dates the Dadupanthi Panchavanis to c. 1600.
Q2. Explain three reasons why historians find it difficult to reconstruct the life of Kabir. [3 marks]
- Late written record: NCERT says every compilation was made long after his death, and Vaudeville (1987) judged that Kabir wrote nothing down.
- Late hagiographies: NCERT dates many to the seventeenth century onwards; McLeod (1992) says the Kabir Parachai reveals very little of his life.
- Rival claims: NCERT notes later debates over whether he was born a Hindu or a Muslim, and chronological problems with the Ramananda link.
Q3. Read the first source box, from NCERT's Source 10, and the paragraph after it. (i) From which two religious traditions do the names come? (ii) What everyday image does the composition use to argue that the names point to one God? (iii) Name two other kinds of terms NCERT says Kabir used for the Ultimate Reality. (iv) Why is the composition described as attributed to Kabir? [4 marks]
- (i) Islamic names such as Allah, Karim and Hazrat, and Hindu names such as Ram, Keshav and Hari.
- (ii) Gold worked into rings and bangles: the shapes differ but the gold stays the same.
- (iii) Vedantic terms such as alakh and nirakar, and yogic terms such as shabda and shunya.
- (iv) NCERT says it may never be possible to tell with certainty which verses are Kabir's.
Q4. Examine how historians use the verses ascribed to Kabir and the hagiographies about him to understand his life and ideas. [8 marks]
- Dating: NCERT places Kabir in c. fourteenth to fifteenth centuries; Vaudeville and Lorenzen place him later.
- Three collections: the Bijak, the Granthavali and the Adi Granth Sahib preserve distinct but overlapping verses (NCERT).
- Dated record: Kohli (1987) dates the Adi Granth to 1604; Vaudeville calls it the oldest dated record of his words.
- Form: the verses survive in several languages, in sant bhasha and as ulatbansi, and were likely sung (NCERT).
- Ideas: they name one Reality as Allah, Ram or Hari and criticise ritual and division, though NCERT finds conflicting ideas.
- Authorship: scholars test language, style and content; Vaudeville says only comparing the three recensions gives a fair picture.
- Hagiographies: NCERT dates many two centuries later; McLeod (1992) finds the Kabir Parachai reveals little biography.
- Ramananda: NCERT doubts they were contemporaries; Lorenzen (1991) argues the discipleship claim can probably be sustained.
Key takeaways
- NCERT dates Kabir to c. fourteenth to fifteenth centuries; Vaudeville (1987) and Lorenzen (1991) place him later, and few details of his life are certain.
- His verses survive in three distinct but overlapping collections, the Kabir Bijak, the Kabir Granthavali and the Adi Granth Sahib, all compiled long after his death.
- The verses use several languages, including sant bhasha, and forms such as the sakhi, the shabda and the upside-down ulatbansi; many were sung.
- The verses name one Ultimate Reality in Islamic, Vedantic and yogic terms and criticise ritual and division, though NCERT notes conflicting ideas.
- NCERT says historians may never know for certain which verses are Kabir's; Vaudeville holds that only comparing the three recensions gives a fair picture.
- The hagiographies date from long after Kabir; historians read them as later memory, and they disagree on whether Ramananda was his guru.
Test yourself
What does the name Kabir mean, according to NCERT?
It is an Arabic word meaning "great", NCERT notes in its account of the hagiographies.
Which group preserves the Kabir Bijak, and where?
The Kabirpanth, in Varanasi and elsewhere in Uttar Pradesh, according to NCERT.
What is an ulatbansi?
An "upside-down saying" that reverses everyday meanings, such as a lotus blooming without flower.
Which collection does Vaudeville call the oldest dated record of Kabir's words?
The Adi Granth Sahib, which Kohli (1987) dates to 1604 at Amritsar.
Why does NCERT doubt that Ramananda taught Kabir?
The verses name no teacher, and the two are hard to make contemporaries without improbably long lives.
What is the earliest known collection of legends about Kabir?
Anantadas's Kabir Parachai, which McLeod (1992) dates towards the end of the sixteenth century.
Write about it
Turn a question from this chapter into a paper.
The Writing Studio has a structure guide, a rubric and citation tools for 15 formats, from essays to research papers. A free account keeps up to five drafts. Learnacy Essential adds feedback from an AI writing coach and submission to The OYI Review.
Publication depends on review and is not guaranteed.
