Entrepreneurship in Action, 21-24 Nov, online. Build a working product with AI

The Cherokee and the Trail of Tears | CBSE Class 11 History Notes

14 min read

On this page

Part of: Displacing Indigenous Peoples (CBSE Class 11 History, Themes in World History, Theme 6). This page deepens one section of that chapter: how native peoples were dispossessed, and what happened to the Cherokee from the 1820s to the forced removal of 1838 to 1839.

Who were the Cherokee, and how had they built a nation by the late 1820s?

The Cherokee call themselves the Ani'Yun'wiya, the Principal People. By the 1820s the Cherokee Nation held land within Georgia, Tennessee, North Carolina and Alabama, with about 16,000 people.

Sequoyah devised a syllabary, a symbol for each sound of the language, and proved it before the Cherokee Council in 1821. It let the Cherokee write and print their laws and newspapers in their own language.

In 1825 the nation made New Echota, near present-day Calhoun, Georgia, its capital. There it adopted a written constitution on 26 July 1827. The Cherokee Phoenix, edited by Elias Boudinot in English and Cherokee, first appeared there on 21 February 1828.

The New Georgia Encyclopedia notes that these steps also told Americans the Cherokee were a sovereign nation that could not be removed without its consent. John Ross, Principal Chief through the crisis, led that case.

Why did Georgia and the federal government press for removal?

Georgia cited the Compact of 1802, in which the federal government had promised to end Indian land title there. A Georgia law of 1828 declared Cherokee laws void from 1 June 1830.

The first documented report of Georgia gold appeared on 1 August 1829. By late 1829 thousands of prospectors had entered Cherokee land, the Great Intrusion. In 1832 Georgia began giving Cherokee land away by lottery.

President Andrew Jackson backed the states. On 28 May 1830 he signed the Indian Removal Act, which let the president negotiate treaties exchanging western land for native lands inside existing states. He argued that removal would save native peoples pressed by settlers and strengthen the south-western frontier.

The Cherokee answered with memorials, formal petitions to Congress. One carried over three thousand signatures, nearly all in the syllabary. Missionaries and Jackson's opponents in Congress took their side.

Source box: two claims from 1830. Cherokee memorial, Cherokee Phoenix, 20 January 1830: "The land on which we stand we have received as an inheritance from our fathers who possessed it from time immemorial..."

Andrew Jackson, message to Congress, 6 December 1830: "Rightly considered, the policy of the General Government toward the red man is not only liberal, but generous."

Question: what gives each side its claim to decide?

The Oklahoma Historical Society counts over 14,000 Choctaw removed from 1831 and over 14,500 Creek (Muscogee) after the war of 1836 to 1837. The Chickasaw also moved, and the Seminole fought a long war from 1835.

What did the Supreme Court decide in the two Cherokee cases?

The Cherokee Nation sued Georgia in the Supreme Court. In Cherokee Nation v. Georgia (1831), Chief Justice John Marshall ruled that the Court could not hear the case, because a native nation was not a "foreign state" under the Constitution.

He called such peoples "domestic dependent nations", in a relation to the United States like "that of a ward to his guardian".

A Georgia law of 1830 required white residents of the Cherokee Nation to hold a state licence. Samuel Worcester and Elizur Butler refused, and in 1831 they were sentenced to four years of hard labour.

On 3 March 1832, in Worcester v. Georgia, the Court reversed their convictions and held the Georgia law void. Relations with the Cherokee belonged to the federal government alone.

PointCherokee Nation v. GeorgiaWorcester v. Georgia
DecisionNo jurisdiction; not a foreign stateGeorgia's law void; convictions reversed
Key idea"Domestic dependent nations"A distinct community beyond Georgia's laws

Source box: John Marshall, opinion in Worcester v. Georgia (1832). "The Cherokee nation, then, is a distinct community occupying its own territory, with boundaries accurately described, in which the laws of Georgia can have no force..."

What it shows: Marshall treated the Cherokee Nation as a bounded territory closed to Georgia's laws. NCERT quotes a shortened form of this sentence.

Why did the judgment of 1832 not stop removal, and where does NCERT simplify?

Georgia refused to obey, and its court would not free the missionaries. NCERT says Jackson "refused to honour" the judgment and ordered the army to evict the Cherokee. Historians generally add three corrections.

  1. No federal order to enforce in 1832. The ruling went to a Georgia court, and the Supreme Court did not call on federal marshals. Jackson did not press Georgia, and he urged the Cherokee to move.
  2. A doubtful quotation. "John Marshall has made his decision; now let him enforce it" is widely quoted, but historians widely regard it as apocryphal. To General John Coffee, Jackson wrote that the decision "has fell still born".
  3. Removal came later, under another president. Its legal basis was the Treaty of New Echota of 1835. The army roundup of 1838 came under Martin Van Buren, president from 4 March 1837, led by General Winfield Scott.

The missionaries were freed in January 1833, after accepting a pardon urged by Georgia's new governor, Wilson Lumpkin. NCERT's main point holds: a court victory did not protect Cherokee land.

How did the Treaty of New Echota divide the Cherokee Nation?

Some leaders came to think resistance was hopeless. Major Ridge, his son John Ridge and Elias Boudinot led this Treaty Party. In the National Park Service's account, they believed the Cherokee could survive as a people only through a treaty. Boudinot lost the Phoenix editorship over the issue in August 1832.

In December 1835 United States officials met this group at New Echota. Only 300 to 500 Cherokee attended, none of them elected officials, and twenty signed.

The treaty traded all Cherokee land east of the Mississippi for $5 million and land in Indian Territory, set aside by Congress in 1834. The Cherokee were to move within two years.

Ross's government rejected the treaty, but the Senate ratified it in May 1836, by a margin of one vote. In 1838 Ross took petitions with over 15,000 Cherokee names to Congress, asking it to void the treaty.

What happened during the forced removal of 1838 to 1839?

Most Cherokee, Ross among them, did not believe they would be forced out. General Scott issued his Orders No. 25 on 17 May 1838, and that month troops and militia began driving families into stockades.

The NPS describes families separated and homes looted. Crowding, poor sanitation and drought in the camps caused many deaths. Scott ordered humane treatment, but the National Archives judges that this did not happen.

In June 1838 three detachments left by water, through low rivers and sickness. Scott then let Ross take charge, and between August and December 1838 Ross organised fourteen more detachments, mostly overland.

Winter trapped many groups between the icy Ohio and Mississippi rivers, and Ross's wife, Quatie, died on the way. Enslaved people held by Cherokee owners were forced along too. The last groups reached Indian Territory, in present-day Oklahoma, by the end of March 1839.

In December 1838 Van Buren told Congress the Cherokee had moved "without any apparent reluctance".

How many people died, and why do the estimates differ?

No one counted the dead precisely. People died in the stockades, on the road and after arrival, so each estimate depends on what it counts. The student should treat every figure as an estimate.

SourceEstimate
NCERTOf 15,000 forced to go, over a quarter died
NPS trail officeOver 1,000 on the journey; perhaps several thousand more from its effects
Elizur Butler, cited by the NPSOver 4,000, nearly a fifth of the Cherokee
National Archives; Library of CongressAbout 4,000, of about 16,000 removed
New Georgia Encyclopedia4,000 to 5,000, by scholars' estimates
Oklahoma Historical SocietyAs many as one in four

The NPS road count is lowest because it is narrowest. About 4,000 deaths among some 16,000 people is about one in four, close to NCERT's figure, though NCERT uses a smaller total of 15,000.

What happened afterwards, and how is the removal remembered?

In Indian Territory the newcomers met about 6,000 Old Settlers, Cherokee who had moved west earlier. Men who had opposed the treaty killed Major Ridge, John Ridge and Boudinot, citing the Cherokee law against selling national land.

The groups met in convention, and on 12 July 1839 they signed an Act of Union. On 6 September 1839 a new constitution was adopted, with Tahlequah as capital. The Cherokee Nation still marks the signing of that constitution with its annual National Holiday.

About 1,000 Cherokee in North Carolina and Tennessee escaped the roundup. Their descendants form the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians, with a tribal government at Cherokee, North Carolina, since 1868.

On 16 December 1987 Congress created the Trail of Tears National Historic Trail, following the water and land routes across nine states. Its partners include the Cherokee Nation and the Eastern Band.

Timeline: when did the key events of Cherokee removal happen?

DateEvent
1821Sequoyah demonstrates his syllabary
1825New Echota becomes the Cherokee capital
26 July 1827The Cherokee constitution is adopted
21 February 1828First issue of the Cherokee Phoenix
1 August 1829First documented report of Georgia gold
28 May 1830Jackson signs the Indian Removal Act
6 December 1830Jackson's message to Congress defends removal
1831Cherokee Nation v. Georgia
3 March 1832Worcester v. Georgia
January 1833The missionaries are released
December 1835Treaty of New Echota signed
May 1836The Senate ratifies the treaty
4 March 1837Van Buren becomes president
May 1838The roundup into stockades begins
August to December 1838Ross organises fourteen detachments
March 1839The last detachments reach Indian Territory
12 July and 6 September 1839Act of Union, then a new constitution
16 December 1987The National Historic Trail is created

Sources: which texts and references support this page?

  • NCERT, Themes in World History, Theme 6, "Displacing Indigenous Peoples", reprint 2026-27 (1832; 15,000 and "over a quarter"); CBSE History syllabus, 2026-27.
  • Cherokee Nation v. Georgia, 30 U.S. 1 (1831); Worcester v. Georgia, 31 U.S. 515 (1832), Cornell LII.
  • US National Archives: Worcester v. Georgia mandate, 3 March 1832; Jackson's message "On Indian Removal", 6 December 1830, Milestone Documents, 2022 (1836; 1838 to 1839).
  • Library of Congress: "Indian Removal Act" guide, 2026 (28 May 1830; 17 May 1838); Jennifer Davis, "Cherokee National Holiday", 2016 (26 July 1827; 12 July and 6 September 1839).
  • National Park Service: Trail of Tears National Historic Trail, "A Brief History" and FAQs, 2025 (1829; 1835; May 1836; 1838; March 1839; December 1987); "The Trail of Tears", Little River Canyon, 2021 (December 1835; 1868); "Cherokee Relations with US Government Before Removal", Fort Smith (1828; 1 June 1830).
  • New Georgia Encyclopedia: Tim Alan Garrison, "Cherokee Removal" and "Worcester v. Georgia", both 2004, edited 2018 (1802; 1825; 1830; 1831; January 1833; 1834; 1835; 1838); David Williams, "Gold Rush", 2003 (1 August 1829); Alice Taylor-Colbert, "John Ross", 2004 (1832; 1839).
  • Encyclopedia of Oklahoma History and Culture, consulted 2026: "Sequoyah" (1821); "Cherokee Phoenix" (21 February 1828; August 1832); "Trail of Tears" (1831; 1836 to 1837); "Cherokee" (1838 to 1839).
  • Miller Center, University of Virginia, consulted 2026: "Andrew Jackson: Domestic Affairs" (1830; 1835); "Martin Van Buren" (4 March 1837; December 1838).
  • Memorial of the Cherokee Nation, Cherokee Phoenix, 20 January 1830 (Western Carolina University).

Glossary

  • Syllabary: a writing system with one symbol for each syllable, such as the one Sequoyah demonstrated in 1821.
  • Indian Removal Act: the law of 28 May 1830 letting the president trade western land for native lands by treaty.
  • Domestic dependent nations: Marshall's phrase of 1831 for native nations under United States protection that were not foreign states.
  • Treaty Party: the minority faction led by the Ridges and Boudinot that signed the Treaty of New Echota in 1835.
  • Stockade: a fenced camp where soldiers held Cherokee families after the roundup of May 1838.
  • Indian Territory: western land set aside for removed nations, in present-day Oklahoma.
  • Act of Union: the agreement of 1839 joining the new arrivals and the Old Settlers as one nation.

Common errors and misconceptions

  • Misconception: In 1832 Jackson defied an order to send troops. Correct: The ruling went to a Georgia court and called on no marshals; Jackson simply would not press Georgia.
  • Misconception: Jackson's army carried out the removal. Correct: The treaty was ratified under Jackson in 1836, but the army roundup came in 1838 under Van Buren, led by Scott.
  • Misconception: The Cherokee government agreed to the Treaty of New Echota. Correct: A minority signed it without Ross's authority, and petitions with over 15,000 names opposed it.
  • Misconception: The death toll is known exactly. Correct: Estimates run from over 1,000 on the road (NPS) to about 4,000 or more in all.
  • Misconception: Every Cherokee was removed in 1838. Correct: About 1,000 escaped and became the Eastern Band, and about 6,000 Old Settlers already lived in the west.

Exam-style questions with model answers

Q1. Which agreement, signed by a minority in December 1835, gave up the Cherokee homelands? (a) Treaty of Hopewell (b) Treaty of New Echota (c) Treaty of Fort Smith (d) Act of Union [1 mark]

(b) Treaty of New Echota. The Treaty Party signed it without Principal Chief John Ross's authority, and the Senate ratified it in 1836.

Q2. Distinguish between Cherokee Nation v. Georgia (1831) and Worcester v. Georgia (1832). [3 marks]
  1. Parties: the Cherokee Nation itself brought the first; convicted missionaries brought the second.
  2. Decision: in 1831 the Court found it had no jurisdiction over a nation that was not a foreign state; in 1832 it reversed the convictions.
  3. Idea: the first called the Cherokee "domestic dependent nations"; the second held that Georgia's laws had no force in Cherokee territory.
Q3. Read Marshall's words of 1832: "The Cherokee nation, then, is a distinct community occupying its own territory, with boundaries accurately described, in which the laws of Georgia can have no force..." (i) What did he say of Georgia's laws? (ii) What happened to the missionaries' convictions? (iii) Give two reasons the judgment did not prevent removal. [4 marks]
  1. (i) Georgia's laws could have no force inside the Cherokee Nation's own territory.
  2. (ii) It reversed them and held the Georgia licence law void.
  3. (iii) Georgia refused to obey, and no federal marshals were called on to make it comply.
  4. (iii) A minority treaty of 1835 later gave a legal basis for removal, which the army carried out in 1838.
Q4. Examine the causes and course of the Cherokee removal of 1838 to 1839. [8 marks]
  1. Land: Georgia claimed Cherokee land under the Compact of 1802 and in 1828 declared Cherokee laws void.
  2. Gold: the gold rush of 1829 brought thousands of intruders onto Cherokee land.
  3. Policy: Jackson backed the states, and the Indian Removal Act of 1830 let him exchange land by treaty.
  4. Resistance: the Cherokee pointed to their constitution of 1827 and sent memorials to Congress.
  5. Courts: Worcester v. Georgia (1832) upheld Cherokee rights, but Georgia ignored it and no federal force was used.
  6. Treaty: a minority signed the Treaty of New Echota in 1835, ratified in 1836 despite mass petitions.
  7. Roundup: in May 1838, under Van Buren, Scott's troops drove families into stockades, where many died.
  8. Journey: detachments went by water and road until March 1839; estimates of the dead run from over 1,000 to 4,000 or more.

Key takeaways

  • By 1828 the Cherokee Nation had a syllabary, a capital, a written constitution and a newspaper, and claimed sovereign rights.
  • Georgia's claims, the gold rush of 1829 and the Indian Removal Act of 1830 turned pressure on Cherokee land into federal policy.
  • In 1831 the Supreme Court refused jurisdiction; in 1832 it held that Georgia's laws had no force in Cherokee territory.
  • Georgia defied the ruling, the Court called on no marshals and Jackson would not press the state, so the victory brought no protection.
  • A minority treaty of 1835, ratified in 1836, was the legal basis for the army's removal of 1838 under Van Buren.
  • Death estimates run from over 1,000 on the road to about 4,000 or more; a trail created in 1987 marks the routes.

Test yourself

Who devised the Cherokee syllabary, and when?

Sequoyah, who showed the Cherokee Council his symbol for each sound in 1821.

What did Georgia's licence law of 1830 require?

White residents of the Cherokee Nation needed a state licence; Worcester and Butler refused and were arrested.

What phrase did Marshall use for native nations in 1831?

"Domestic dependent nations", whose relation to the United States resembled that of a ward to a guardian.

Why did John Ross reject the Treaty of New Echota?

A minority without authority from the elected government had signed it, and most Cherokee opposed it.

Who was president during the roundup of 1838, and who led the troops?

Martin Van Buren was president; General Winfield Scott commanded the troops.

What is the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians?

Cherokee who escaped removal, with a tribal government at Cherokee, North Carolina, since 1868.

Write about it

Turn a question from this chapter into a paper.

The Writing Studio has a structure guide, a rubric and citation tools for 15 formats, from essays to research papers. A free account keeps up to five drafts. Learnacy Essential adds feedback from an AI writing coach and submission to The OYI Review.

Publication depends on review and is not guaranteed.